mojira.dev
MCPE-28657

Observers triggered by redstone has inconsistent timing

Phone : Huawei P9

The redstone delay from an a piece of restone activating till an observer outputs power varies to such a large degree that timing sensitive redstone cuircuits are currently not possible.

Test world attached with 2 rows of 6 double piston extenders - one using redstone ontop of observers to trigger the top piston (A) and one triggering it directly with redstone ontop of the piston (B)

B works every time
A works randomly

Video illustrating issue:
https://youtu.be/etqt07lbPGI

In the test world delete retracted bookshelves and place new ones infront of the haybales to reset ( reset cuircuit is not included to keep the restone to the bare bug )

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 16

[media][media][media]
[media][media][media]
[media][media][media]
Morten Haggren

Added world download with timings corrected for beta.

(A) is still in consistent
(B) Still works

Added world download with timings corrected for beta.

(A) is still in consistent
(B) Still works

6 more comments
Morten Haggren

@wakafu mafuyuu - even so it should either always fail to pull a block or always pull a block - as shown it does both on the same tick. This is inconsistent - hence the title of the bug report 😉 You can't have reliable circuits if you introduce a random factor

@wakafu mafuyuu - even so it should either always fail to pull a block or always pull a block - as shown it does both on the same tick. This is inconsistent - hence the title of the bug report 😉 You can't have reliable circuits if you introduce a random factor

@wakafu mafuyuu - even so it should either always fail to pull a block or always pull a block - as shown it does both on the same tick. This is inconsistent - hence the title of the bug report 😉 You can't have reliable circuits if you introduce a random factor

@wakafu mafuyuu - even so it should either always fail to pull a block or always pull a block - as shown it does both on the same tick. This is inconsistent - hence the title of the bug report 😉 You can't have reliable circuits if you introduce a random factor

SuperGeniusZeb

Duplicate of the ever-annoying MCPE-15793.

Morten Haggren

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Android

Android 7.0

1.2.3.6, 1.2.5.15, 1.2.6.2

Retrieved