mojira.dev
MCPE-33747

Kelp cannot be placed on most kinds of blocks

Kelp cannot be placed on most kinds of solid blocks. The only kinds I have found it can be placed on are dirt, coarse dirt, sand, and gravel. If placed on dirt and the dirt changes to grass (due to MCPE-32671), the kelp will break the next time the block is updated.

The wiki doesn't mention that kelp can only be placed on certain blocks. I expect this is an oversight, but we need to know which kinds of blocks kelp is intended to be placeable on.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 5

A sample of some of the blocks where kelp can be placed, Java vs Bedrock:

[media]

A sample of some of the blocks where kelp can be placed, Java vs Bedrock:

[media]

If kelp can't grow on anything other than soil like land in real life, then this would be intentional. Does it even make sense for kelp to grow/be placed on any type of block?

If kelp can't grow on anything other than soil like land in real life, then this would be intentional. Does it even make sense for kelp to grow/be placed on any type of block?

Auldrick

(Unassigned)

121643

Confirmed

Windows

Windows 10 version 1803

1.4.2.0

1.6.0

Retrieved