[MCPE-46675] Planting beetroot, melon, and pumpkin seeds makes a wood placing sound

When planting beetroot, watermelon and pumpkin seeds, it makes the sound like you were placing a block of wood.

Placing/breaking Crop	Sound
Wheat/potato/carrot	Grass breaking sound
Beetroot/Pumpkin/Melon	Wood placing sound

Video: https://youtu.be/yPKtVMBENDw

Linked issues

is duplicated by 20

MCPE-182407 The sound of wood from beetroot, watermelon and pumpkin seeds Resolved

MCPE-180349 Beetroot has incorrect sounds when farming Resolved

MCPE-177073 Beetroot Sound Incorrect Resolved

MCPE-174719 Placing/ breaking Beetroot seeds on farmland plays the same sound as placing/breaking wood Resolved

MCPE-149390 Planting a Beet seed makes a wooden plank sound Resolved

15 more links

Comments 8

Lloyd Lewis 2019-05-28T03:37:02Z

I just noticed today that it makes the same wood placing sound when planting pumpkin and melons as well.

Minecraft Lover 2019-09-22T16:00:28Z

Me too i reported this before this, so your report is a duplicate.

😉

Lloyd Lewis 2019-12-16T15:53:04Z

Still the same in 1.14.0

Rishit Shetty 2020-06-07T12:05:45Z

Lloyd Lewis, the pumpkin and melon makes the same sound as in Java edition.

So maybe it's not a bug and just intentional.

xXGlitchSlayerXx 2021-01-13T17:07:01Z

This bug is referencing Missing crop sounds that were added to Java 1.14.

osfanbuff63 2021-01-23T20:25:56Z

Can confirm in 1.16.201 on Android! But I think this is only for the beetroots, not pumpkins and melons. I think the pumpkin and melon sounds are intended to be the wood breaking sounds.

osfanbuff63 2021-01-23T20:28:42Z

This also happens when placing beetroot seeds, not just breaking them!

TheMightyDark 2024-07-03T23:46:30Z

This issue is really easy to fix. All Mojang has to do is change the sound event for melon and pumpkin stems, and beetroot to match wheat crops.