mojira.dev
MCPE-64252

Hoppers dont drop out from destroyed hopper minecarts

Tested 100 minecarts being destroyed by cactus
Zero hoppers dropped.
Tried with skeletons fireing also zero dropped.
Exploding Tnt drops some but It should be all.

*Additional information by [~Auldrick]:*

In Survival mode:

Destroyed by

Drops: Minecart

Hopper

Hopper Contents

Cactus

Yes

No

Yes

Arrow

Yes

No

Yes

TNT

Yes

No

Yes

Pickaxe

Yes

Yes

Yes

In Creative mode:

Destroyed by

Drops: Minecart

Hopper

Hopper Contents

Cactus

Yes

No

Yes

Arrow

No

No

No

TNT

No

No

No

Pickaxe

No

No

Yes

In testing with cactus, there was a possibility that the hopper might land on the cactus and being destroyed. I used a hopper under the rail to try to grab the drops before this could happen. The hopper successfully grabbed the minecart and/or hopper contents, but never a hopper.

To test with an arrow in Creative, you have to initially aim at something else, then slide to target the minecart with hopper while holding down the use control.

Related issues

Comments

GoldenHelmet

According to the 1.15.0.55 beta changelog:

  • Hopper mine carts will now drop hoppers and mine carts when broken with a ranged weapon (MCPE-55859)

Can you verify whether this has also fixed the hoppers dropping with other methods of breaking?

Vocktile

I can sometime whithin the next 24hours, maybe, i got work atm so will leave an update when i check.

Vocktile

This has indeed corrected the drops for every method i tested.

Creative.

Cactus, minecrat yes, hopper yes, content yes
Dispenser arrow, minecart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Bow arrow, minecarft no, hopper no, content no
TnT, minecrart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Skeleton arrow, minecart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Pickaxe, minecart no, hopper no, content yes

Survival

Cactus, minecrat yes, hopper yes, content yes
Dispenser arrow, minecart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Bow arrow, minecarft yes, hopper yes, content yes
TnT, minecrart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Skeleton arrow, minecart yes, hopper yes, content yes
Pickaxe, minecart yes, hopper yes, content yes

Vocktile

It aslo works for tridents

Vocktile

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Windows

Windows 10

1.15.0.53 Beta, 1.14.30 Hotfix

1.16.0.64 Beta, 1.16.0

Retrieved