mojira.dev
MCPE-65070

Unbreaking Enchanted Tools Breaking Sound Inconsistency

What Happens:
Any tool enchanted with unbreaking of any level can cause the breaking sound to either play without the item breaking, or break without the sound, at random. This only happens when breaking blocks. It also occurs with the sword.

What’s Expected
When a tool with unbreaking finally breaks, it only then makes the breaking sound and then is gone from the inventory.

Reproduce
1. Get any tool, (pickaxe, shovel, shears, etc.) preferably with a durability of 1 for ease of testing.
2. Enchant said tool with unbreaking of any level.
3. Mine the appropriate block for the tool until the tool breaks.
4. Observe that the tool will either break without a sound or make the breaking sound and remain unbroken.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 2

Confirmed. My theory is that this is some kind of RNG client-server desync.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

We believe this was fixed in an earlier version.

PikaBlu

(Unassigned)

386684

Confirmed

iOS

iPadOS 13.4

Enchantment, Sound, Unbreaking

1.14.30 Hotfix, 1.14.60 Hotfix

1.16.221 Hotfix

Retrieved