[REALMS-5918] Xbox Live Club not created for Realm

An Xbox Live Club was not automatically created when I created the realm, which disables the ability for players to share screenshots to the realm feed. The feed is stuck on the loading screen when I try to load it. It may be possible that clubs are no longer supported, as they do not appear in the new Xbox App for mobile and Windows 10. On the Xbox Console Companion app for Windows I am still able to see clubs for realms I am a member of, but there is no club for my realm. I am also still able to post screenshots on these realms. When I created a realm a few months ago, a club was immediately created.

Linked issues

is duplicated by 28

BDS-10610 Realms feed not working? Resolved

BDS-11088 Minecraft realms feed fails to load. Resolved

MCPE-109262 Feed not loading in realms on any platform I tired Windows 10, ps4, IOS Resolved

MCPE-111244 I can't see my feed on my realm (IT STILL DOESNT WORK) Resolved

MCPE-111708 Feed fails to load. For quite some time now the screenshots on my feed on any realm don't load, only the words show. Resolved

23 more links

Comments 31

[Mod] Umija5895M 2020-11-02T12:58:23Z

Please check your Xbox Live privacy settings to make sure that the setting for
You can create and join clubs is on
If not, try turning it on and see if you can then create the club.

This ticket has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response. It will automatically reopen when you add information.

migrated 2020-11-02T15:27:47Z

The You can create and join clubs setting was already set to Allow.

migrated 2020-11-03T17:42:43Z

The same thing is happening to me /:

Its nothing wrong with the privacy settings. I've checked every setting to even check. Its a bug on mojangs side. They need to take action and fix it. I don't spend money for a broken feature.

migrated 2020-11-11T22:35:45Z

Can someone at least help us? We don't pay for a broken feature yk

[Mod] Umija5895M 2020-11-11T23:01:47Z

This site is primarily intended for reporting bugs, it is not a technical / customer support site.

You might want to visit Community Support or Mojang Support for help.

21 more comments

CornerHard 2020-11-12T00:55:21Z

Indeed, this Realm is missing a Club - very strange! Do you have any details about how you signed up for the Realm? I see your other previous Realms were assigned Clubs like normal.

migrated 2020-11-12T01:47:56Z

I purchased the Realm on the Nintendo Switch version using Minecoins (the same way I bought realms before), except this time I clicked "Renew" on my 10 player Realm instead of adding a new one. It didn't renew the previous Realm, and created a new one instead, which is fine, but no Club was created.

migrated 2020-11-12T15:25:30Z

We've found the issue with the clubs integration, and I'm working on a fix. once we get the fix in place and deployed to production, clubs should be created for the realm again after the first successful restart of the realm. I don't have an ETA as of yet, we have to work with a partner team to resolve the issue.

migrated 2020-11-23T09:46:47Z

I have the same problem. I hope this bug will be fixed soon

migrated 2020-12-09T22:27:24Z

Same issue here! Was directed to this bug tracker by Mojang support.

migrated 2020-12-10T00:12:10Z

I was also given the same problem. This isn't game breaking, but it makes some things harder (hard to explain).
Also, after going through a long list, I was directed here, after being directed to email addresses.

migrated 2020-12-23T21:01:43Z

I am having the same issue with my realm. I appreciate you Cullen for working on this, I really hope that we can get this fixed soon. I really want my players to be able to post about things on a club that is tied to the realm.

migrated 2020-12-28T01:58:27Z

I believe it is when you create your 2nd realm, this one is my second and someone else also mentioned having one, however please tell me if I'm wrong.

migrated 2020-12-28T09:50:03Z

Having the same issue.
I own 3 Realms.
The first one has a Club the two new Realms didnt get a club. Please get a fix @Mojang

Realm restart doesnt create a club for me. Any new Informations?

If you need more Infos please contact.

migrated 2021-01-04T23:54:18Z

I am having the same issue

migrated 2021-01-05T03:33:28Z

Also having this issue - verified all permissions and even created trial realm to test.

migrated 2021-01-15T22:30:33Z

What's the latest here? I'm assuming you need the Xbox team to partner on this and address the issue... $7.99 a month where I'm perfectly capable of running my own server. I pay for the X-platform interaction.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay) 2021-01-27T16:45:26Z

Thank you for your patience while we get this matter addressed. For those still affected, is the issue only occurring on Xbox One now, or are you seeing this on other platforms also?

migrated 2021-01-27T17:09:46Z

The issue occurs on all platforms. Any new realm created as of now does not get a club, and so nobody on any platform is able to view the club or realm feed.

migrated 2021-01-27T17:30:21Z

I know it’s affecting realms I use that were created through both Windows 10 as well as PS4.

Edit* - This happened for even the very first realms created by a friend on PS4 and then me on Windows 10. Screenshot added from Windows 10 (realm name blacked out for privacy).

migrated 2021-01-27T18:33:51Z

As mentioned above, this occurs on any realm created on any platform after creating the first realm. I created all three of my realms on my phones(I've switched since making them) and only have a club on my first, which I didn't repay, I just let it end since no one else played with me. I am currently paying for these subscriptions, your Realms service has been fairly good, better than what I used 'forehand, however, the ui glitches and this are just not what I had in mind. It would be most appreciated if you could rectify this issue at a higher rate of importance than what it may have seemed to be earlier.

osfanbuff63 2021-01-28T22:43:21Z

This issue did not happen to me in my new realm that was created 2 days ago on 1.16.201; the realm feed works fine! Mine was created on iOS.

migrated 2021-01-28T23:55:11Z

Looks like the issue is fixed! All realms I am in now have feeds.

migrated 2021-01-29T04:17:13Z

Same here. The 2 realms I had issues on are now working as I'd expect them to.

migrated 2021-01-29T15:13:32Z

We deployed a fix for this issue to production this week.

migrated 2021-01-29T17:31:08Z

I’m still having the same issue on my two realms.

Auldrick 2021-01-29T18:26:00Z

@unknown: We've often noticed that patches to Realms can take a few days to propagate through the servers and individual Realm images. Please check again in a few days and let us know if you continue to have a problem.

You might also want to try the solution suggested in this Xbox support document if you haven't already done so.

migrated 2021-01-29T18:50:30Z

You are correct! 1 of 2 of my realms is working now. Thanks guys! 😃👍

migrated 2021-02-05T08:55:01Z

When I post to the feed nothing is shown on feed. Anyone having the same problem?

migrated 2021-02-05T12:54:59Z

@Eduardo - I am not, however I know my friends on PS4 are not able to post to the feed, but they can see my posts.

Auldrick 2021-02-05T14:24:41Z

@unknown: I played around with my Realm feed a bit and it seems to me that there's a pretty significant delay at times between creating a new post and it becoming incorporated into the feed. It looks to me like this delay is in the Xbox Live network interaction, not in the game. If your problem doesn't resolve itself within a few minutes, it's probably best to create a new Mojira ticket to report it, though I expect it's not Mojang who needs to fix it but the Xbox team.

@unknown: ~~I'm pretty sure your friends' problem is being caused by their Xbox settings.~~ If they're playing on child accounts, they should involve their parent in troubleshooting the issue. If they can't solve the issue themselves, they should look to Xbox Support for help. Edit After some more experimentation, there definitely seem to be some problems with everybody seeing the same feed content. As with Eduardo's issue, it's best to report it in a new report. Try to capture it in screenshots if you can.