I post lots of ideas on the site, and most of the ideas will not come through as an official idea. No emails were sent to me about my project being blocked, unaccepted, or officialy posted. Though on the website it specifically says "
DON’T SEE YOUR IDEA?
As people are automatically subscribed to threads they post, you should check your email for notifications to see if any of your posts have been removed before reposting. Also check the junk filter, especially if you are posting a lot of messages. Typically, if a message is removed from view, a note is made by an admin, which triggers a message to the original poster, then we close the thread and remove it from view. Repeated reposts are considered spam, so please make sure your email account is connected to something you check often." Please fix the issue.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 12
WEB-1996
Emails not being sent after ideas are shot down
Resolved
WEB-2962
all of my posts on the feedback page keep getting deleted with no email or anything.
Resolved
WEB-3404
What did I do wrong?
Resolved
WEB-3844
I cant find my feedback
Resolved
WEB-4388
Cannot post any feedback with an external links
Resolved
relates to 1
Comments 11
I can confirm this is happening (and am responsible for one of the dupes of this issue). I've tried posting a comment multiple times and, while I have my suspicions on why it was rejected the first two times, I am nonetheless hesitant to post it a third time without knowing for certain. Checked my inbox and spam folder; zilch!
I am using either my Outlook or Gmail, if that helps. Not positive which but I think the former.
is there any workaround for this at least, such as an activity feed somewhere on the site? do the mods get mad if I just go to trial and error on it until I get approved?
The fact this has been open since at least March of last year is kind of disappointing, since it's probably not doing anything to help the efficiency of the moderation team if their rejection reason isn't being reliably communicated.
This is because of WEB-4529 I think
Are you meant to get an email saying it is submitted? I would assume so but no dice, at least in my experience.
@unknown, this is still an issue as of 22 December 2024. I created a feedback post and did not get an email about the post being gone. That post was well detailed though.
Is this still an issue for those who were affected?
This issue is being temporarily resolved as Awaiting Response. Once the requested information has been delivered, the report will be reopened automatically.
Quick Links:
📓 Bug Tracker Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Mojang Support (Technical Issues) – 📧 Microsoft Support (Account Issues)
📓 Project Summary – ✍️ Feedback and Suggestions – 📖 Web Services Wiki
The feedback site doesn't seem to be able to send emails at all. I've heard multiple reports about this on Discord, and I myself have never received any emails from that site either.