mojira.dev

BugHater

Assigned

No issues.

Reported

MC-142628 Grindstone sound is unbearable! Invalid

Comments

This issue is still present in 1.15-pre1.

What is even more surprising that it is still UNASSIGNED!

IMHO, item deletion is a serious bug and should be prioritized.

 

The grindstone sound literally makes my skin crawl.  I cringe when I hear it.  The volume is not an issue, the sound is unpleasant at any volume.

Why? I think it is because the grindstone sound is similar to the following sounds many people find unpleasant:

1) Styrofoam rubbing against styrofoam
2) Fork scraping against plate
3) Fingernails on chalkboard

Here is a good article about such sounds:
https://www.wired.com/2011/11/chalk-board-fingernail-sound/

“Works As Intended”? Really???  This reminds me of an old joke:

— “How many Microsoft Developers does it take to change a light bulb?”

— “NONE.  Microsoft would just declare darkness a new industry standard!”

OK, seriously:

  • ·         I believe this bug stems from /locate command bug (see MC-126244). The same code is probably called when trading with cartographers, throwing eyes of ender, etc.

  • ·          “A range of 100 chunks in every direction” in version 1.12.2 is simply not true.  100 regions (51200 blocks) – maybe, but definitely not 1600 blocks.

  • ·         The /locate command finds ALL STRUCTURES, including Strongholds.  So if the intended behavior is to limit its range to 100 chunks, then you can’t find a Stronghold and therefore ”win” the game if there are no Strongholds within 100 chunk radius of spawn.  This is a gamebreaking bug!

  • ·         Cartographers in all the versions 16w39b through 1.12.2 indeed worked as intended. (I had traded with cartographers in those versions across more than 20 different Minecraft worlds without a single problem. The Mansions on cartographers’ maps would almost always be more than 5000 blocks away, often 10k+ blocks away.

  • ·         Most of the 13-snapshots including the latest 1.13-pre6 DO NOT work as intended.

se  Please, remove Version 1.12.2 from affected versions and reopen the issue for 13-snapshots.