Mikael Levan

Thank you for quick reply 🙂

This is not resolved. My villager farmer still does not create bread/share with his friends. (I am on 1.14.2 release). Or does the "Fix Version/s:Future Version - 1.14+" mean that a patch is still to come?

affects pre-release 4

more detailed commentry here https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-152084

affects pre-release 4

more detailed commentry here https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-152084

pre-release 4: 

 There is still an issue with  villagers and beds,  some of my (farmer) villagers will not use their beds at night. The affected villagers will not even go inside. They just stand in their fields all night. Luckily the field is walled off so zombies can't get to them (only way to leave the field is to enter their respective houses). 

*breaking their beds and placing new beds did not help.

*trading with the affected villagers did not help

*the walled off farm with connecting house is a "cloned" design I use on several locations and on other exact duplicates of this setup the villagers go to bed at dusk like they supposed to, so there is nothing about the design/layout that prevents them from sleeping at night.

*I have not seen if the affected villagers "stood up" at night like the reporter describes it in order to trigger this behaviour, all I know is that they used to sleep perfectly fine in their beds every night, and at some point they just stopped sleeping (I have played this world since 1.14 first snapshot).

*I have not changed anything about the design of the house, the field outside or the walls that surround the field.

quote Anomie X:  "all villagers with the ability to craft bread (currently all of them) should do so for their own use instead of only for sharing,"

yes I agree that own use + also sharing is OK, but must still be able to share to others also, otherwise will break many bread farms that players have created that depend on the farmer villager sharing the bread. So a NO for crafting for own use only. 

(I think this is what Anomie was already saying but not 100% sure?)

I have automated bread, carrot, potato and beetroot farms that relies on the farmer villager to throw food to other villagers behind minecarts with hoppers. 

Carrot, beetroot and potato work fine, hoppers intercept and transport the thrown food to chest below.

My bread chest is empty 😞 the farmer working the wheat field does not throw any bread to his hungry friends. Several hours played already on 1,14,2 pre-release 3, not a single bread thrown 😞

I am playing 1.14.2 pre-release 3 now. I have 4 fields, one for each harvest type (beetroot, wheat, carrot, potato).  Each field has one villager farmer working on it. Each field is 6x15 blocks in a square fashion, like so: 

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

Water access is sufficient and there are 2 composters on left side and 2 more on the right side of each field (can there be a problem if use more than 1 composter per field? I did it like this for symmetrical/decorational reasons).

On every single one of these 4 fields the villager farmer has planted more or less half of the field and the other half is unplanted (either left side or right side, but different sides depending on what field you are looking at). It is almost (but not exactly) like there is some invisible line in the middle which they will not cross. They have now either stopped working, or working so slow that it is not noticeable. Sometimes they break and replant on the side that is already full, but they will not touch the side that requires work.

It is now 3 real life hours of play time since they started re-planting the fields (after last time the fields were harvested clean). That equals more or less to 15 planted blocks per real-time hours played. I have tossed seeds/vegetables at the villagers and I have seen them pick up, so in their inventories there should be enough to plant each field fully.

In 1.14 earlier snapshots they managed to plant 100% of all four fields and they did it fast and efficient. Nothing significant has changed on my part (no new villagers, doors, beds, or houses has been introduced and the number of composters were 4 per field also back then).

Hoping that something can be done/fixed to speed up the villager farming and that they can hopefully better start detecting what farmland blocks are still unplanted and prioritize planting those blocks first.

Best of wishes & thanks for making the best game in the world. 

Ei_Ei