mojira.dev
MC-109473

End portal doesn't have perspective and depth

I just realised that the end portal doesn't have perspective movement and depth which was in versions prior to the 1.11 snapshots now it looks more like the end gateway.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments

kumasasa

Confirmed.

1.10.2 ...16w39c: The end portal is bound to the environment
16w40a .. 16w43a The end portal is bound to player's cursor

serjproch

And?
"Works As Intended" - Where and who said it?
Reopen issue and fix it
or set resulion "we wont fix it"

serjproch

The end portal block rendering has to be as prior 1.11 and not as "end gateway"
To replace 3d mechanics with 2d and say "works as intended" it means say nothing/
Is there any specialists with 3d-programming in your company?
Or may be it's time to make minecraft 2d-rendering and say "works as intended"?

user-f2760

Read the history or look at the assignee field.

@unknown made changes - 04/Nov/16 9:18 AM

Resolution

Works As Intended [ 6 ]

Assignee

@unknown [ excited ]

Status

Open [ 1 ]

Resolved [ 5 ]

serjproch

Who is "Maria Lemón"? The God?
Just set resolution "we wont fix it" or "we have no good programmers to do that"

user-f2760

It's intended, and maria is a mojang employee (as you can see by the prefix).

serjproch

does maria decide by herself what is intented and what is not?
Who must decide this?

bemoty

@unknown Probably not, but does it matter? This has been confirmed to be working as intended by Mojang.
This is a bug tracker, not a forum. If you want to discuss, please head over to the official Minecraft Subreddit.

serjproch

Oкеу
Give please url to that mojang article where it has been confirmed
I can't find it
😞

bemoty

The URL is https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MC-109473 – this is the official bug tracker for Mojang games; this report has been resolved as working as intended by a Mojang employee, which confirms it.

Sphax

I agree this is a bad decision to say it "Works as intended"... The effect since 1.11 is very ugly and frustrating (because the image basically follows the cursor) while it was a nice Parallax effect before with depth sensation.

The new FX is like a 2D texture following the cursor... And a 2D texture following the cursor while world does not is very frustrating...

Related Reddit thread: https://www.reddit.com/r/Minecraft/comments/59y3nf/til_since_16w40a_end_portals_rendering_has_changed/

DoggoKingTPG

Doing a starry sky block as a portal would be very hard to do if it didn't bob along, so this leads me to believe that this works as intended.

lynrayy

@unknown 
Just try to look to end portal in 1.4.6 version.

it is NOT WORKING "As Intended"
It is BROKEN and ugly

lynrayy

Maybe mojang changed their mind since 2017? (6 years ago)
Reopen please 

Reopen issue and fix it
or set resulion "we wont fix it"

user-f2760

Unless you have any grounds for objectively requesting a review that's not just "looks bad", or any grounds that indicate mojang might actually be reconsidering, not just "what if", then this won't get reopened.

Mojang made a clear choice to change it, and resolved this as intended, and have shown no indication to be changing their minds.

Greg Milson

migrated

Confirmed

Minecraft 16w42a, Minecraft 16w43a

Retrieved