mojira.dev
MC-115070

Issue with crafting table UI on non-16:9 instances

Mod Notice

4:3 is WAI.

– @unknown in this comment

The bug

When running Minecraft at an aspect ratio taller than 16:9, the crafting UI changes. Normally, when you use the new recipe book in a crafting table, it will appear beside the crafting table UI, so that you can view and craft at the same time.

However, in taller aspect ratios than 16:9, this functionality is lost, because the UI appears above the crafting table, and when any recipes are clicked, the UI disappears, but the recipe does not show up on the crafting grid.

To be clear, the UI works fine with aspect ratios SHORTER than 16:9, so 16:8, etc, works fine. But things like 3:2, 4:3, or 1:1, or example, don't work.

Problems

  • As described in MC-115071 the "inventory" rendered behind the crafting help is not actually the player inventory. The slots appear always empty even if the player has items in these slots.

  • The player model is rendered in gray in front of the recipe book GUI, see MC-116761.

Note from original poster

I'm actually no longer experiencing this issue. On my device, it works fine. For me, It was fixed in 17w14a, but still affects other people. Not sure if this information is important, but thought I would mention it.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 16

marcono1234

and when any recipes are clicked, the UI disappears, but the recipe does not show up on the crafting grid.

Cannot confirm that. For me the crafting recipe appears in the crafting grid.

capfan

Testing with 17w14a. This issue still happens.

Game set to 1024x768. Open crafting table. This is the resulting GUI: http://i.imgur.com/RrN1lkk.png

marcono1234

It looks like this is still the case in 17w15a

Edit: I thought this report described the fact that the recipe book looks different for smaller display ratios.

[Mod]Les3awe

It does not seem to affect me.
Still affect the resolution 4:3.

wobst.michael

Was able to reproduce it with for example 1600x1200. See

[media]
6 more comments
capfan

Maria Lemon, This issue occurs when you select any 4:3 aspect ratio. Here is a screenshot of 1.12-Pre6 at 1280x960: http://i.imgur.com/KUjPzjF.png

If this were happening at some wacky resolution that no one uses, this might be a non issue. The trouble is, this happens at the default 4:3 monitor resolution and impacts a meaningful number of people.

kuemmi

I think the issue is Minecraft calculating the Auto GUI scale by the size of the normal inventory, thus (mostly) setting the GUI scale to Large which leads to the recipe book overlapping the inventory on 4:3 screens.

SunCat

@unknown, the way it happens on your screenshot is intended:

Since this is how it should look if the screen is not big enough for the GUI.

It just can't fit if you have it on the side. Also, it should behave the way you want if you change the GUI scale to normal, as there would be space to fit both inventory and recipe book side by side.

Maria Lemón

4:3 is WAI.

capfan

I think the issue is Minecraft calculating the Auto GUI scale by the size of the normal inventory, thus (mostly) setting the GUI scale to Large which leads to the recipe book overlapping the inventory on 4:3 screens.

In fact, this is exactly it. at the 1280x960 resolution I was testing, "Large" works fine but "Auto" sets the GUI scale to a size larger than "large" and the inventory subsequently fails. This isn't the only failure, as a number of option menus are also cropped on the sides.

Having said that, I suspect "Auto" being the real problem makes this report a duplicate of MC-37839.

MasterMindDude

migrated

Confirmed

crafting, crafting_table, screen-ratio

Minecraft 17w13a, Minecraft 17w14a, Minecraft 17w15a, Minecraft 17w17b, Minecraft 17w18a, Minecraft 17w18b

Minecraft 17w15a, Minecraft 1.12 Pre-Release 1

Retrieved