[MC-11790] Since the advent of 1.5, we can no longer put a water seal on the snow, water is placed in the block above the snow

Since the advent of 1.5, we can no longer put a water seal on the snow, water is placed in the block above the snow, and not instead of right click, whereas before the snow was replaced by water, now the water is raised above the snow (not the block of snow, snow)

What I expected to happen was...:
The snow should have been replaced by water in the place of my right click.
What actually happened was...:
The water was placed in the block above

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Right click with a bucket of water on the snow.

version before : http://www.tooPix.eu/b5eb7f53c641ce82039e4ff6b1adf8c5.html ( screenshot )
1.5 version : http://www.tooPix.eu/9bf67302b800224ffbdc8558764c6329.html ( screenshot again )

Linked issues

is duplicated by 3

MC-12502 Pouring a water bucket on snow does not replace the snow Resolved

MC-17106 Water on Snow Resolved

MC-79532 Water and lava can't replace snow. Resolved

relates to 3

MC-130761 Liquids are placed next to replaceable blocks (tall grass, snow layer) instead of inside it Open

MC-64139 Cannot place banner or sign on snow layer level 1 Resolved

MC-92868 Water gets placed above snow layer higher than 1 Resolved

Attachments

Comments 6

Cocun 2013-03-14T17:58:56Z

Minecraft has crashed!      
      ----------------------      

Minecraft has stopped running because it encountered a problem; Manually triggered debug crash

A full error report has been saved to C:\Users\killian\AppData\Roaming\.minecraft\crash-reports\crash-2013-03-14_18.57.39-client.txt - Please include a copy of that file (Not this screen!) if you report this crash to anyone; without it, they will not be able to help fix the crash :(



--- BEGIN ERROR REPORT 75c6b703 --------
Full report at:
C:\Users\killian\AppData\Roaming\.minecraft\crash-reports\crash-2013-03-14_18.57.39-client.txt
Please show that file to Mojang, NOT just this screen!

Generated 14/03/13 18:57

-- Affected level --
Details:
	Level name: MpServer
	All players: 1 total; [bdp['CoCun'/318, l='MpServer', x=175,48, y=69,88, z=218,08]]
	Chunk stats: MultiplayerChunkCache: 441
	Level seed: 0
	Level generator: ID 00 - default, ver 1. Features enabled: false
	Level generator options: 
	Level spawn location: World: (208,64,236), Chunk: (at 0,4,12 in 13,14; contains blocks 208,0,224 to 223,255,239), Region: (0,0; contains chunks 0,0 to 31,31, blocks 0,0,0 to 511,255,511)
	Level time: 9747 game time, 9626 day time
	Level dimension: 0
	Level storage version: 0x00000 - Unknown?
	Level weather: Rain time: 0 (now: false), thunder time: 0 (now: false)
	Level game mode: Game mode: creative (ID 1). Hardcore: false. Cheats: false
	Forced entities: 125 total; [ql['Squid'/27, l='MpServer', x=112,94, y=60,31, z=223,81], sb['Spider'/28, l='MpServer', x=117,00, y=15,00, z=257,25], rz['Skeleton'/31, l='MpServer', x=135,34, y=23,00, z=235,88], qc['Chicken'/30, l='MpServer', x=142,25, y=62,14, z=228,44], ql['Squid'/34, l='MpServer', x=135,84, y=57,38, z=271,28], sd['Zombie'/32, l='MpServer', x=140,84, y=21,00, z=258,78], rb['item.item.dyePowder.black'/33, l='MpServer', x=132,25, y=45,13, z=276,84], sd['Zombie'/38, l='MpServer', x=152,66, y=22,00, z=212,06], sd['Zombie'/39, l='MpServer', x=153,69, y=23,00, z=212,69], ql['Squid'/37, l='MpServer', x=154,50, y=58,22, z=161,47], qc['Chicken'/42, l='MpServer', x=155,50, y=64,00, z=233,50], rb['item.item.egg'/43, l='MpServer', x=158,53, y=65,13, z=231,56], rz['Skeleton'/40, l='MpServer', x=155,50, y=38,00, z=212,50], ql['Squid'/41, l='MpServer', x=140,66, y=57,03, z=231,47], qc['Chicken'/44, l='MpServer', x=146,59, y=62,35, z=244,41], ro['Creeper'/55, l='MpServer', x=169,50, y=19,00, z=203,75], ro['Creeper'/54, l='MpServer', x=170,50, y=14,00, z=200,50], ro['Creeper'/53, l='MpServer', x=180,13, y=37,00, z=182,72], ro['Creeper'/52, l='MpServer', x=166,50, y=36,00, z=183,00], sd['Zombie'/59, l='MpServer', x=168,50, y=20,00, z=230,50], qa['Bat'/58, l='MpServer', x=168,38, y=24,10, z=208,25], ql['Squid'/57, l='MpServer', x=172,65, y=48,36, z=204,50], ql['Squid'/56, l='MpServer', x=162,84, y=47,37, z=200,47], rz['Skeleton'/63, l='MpServer', x=173,50, y=43,00, z=276,09], rz['Skeleton'/62, l='MpServer', x=170,41, y=16,00, z=266,44], qo['Wolf'/61, l='MpServer', x=171,59, y=66,00, z=253,16], qo['Wolf'/60, l='MpServer', x=166,63, y=63,00, z=249,75], qa['Bat'/70, l='MpServer', x=190,56, y=27,10, z=147,59], rz['Skeleton'/71, l='MpServer', x=188,88, y=23,00, z=152,53], sd['Zombie'/64, l='MpServer', x=164,30, y=20,39, z=289,63], qa['Bat'/65, l='MpServer', x=167,63, y=25,10, z=296,75], qa['Bat'/66, l='MpServer', x=170,47, y=27,10, z=290,13], qo['Wolf'/76, l='MpServer', x=189,06, y=64,00, z=249,50], qo['Wolf'/77, l='MpServer', x=185,28, y=72,00, z=236,59], rz['Skeleton'/78, l='MpServer', x=184,66, y=44,00, z=266,31], rz['Skeleton'/79, l='MpServer', x=189,28, y=43,00, z=264,25], ro['Creeper'/72, l='MpServer', x=188,50, y=23,00, z=148,50], ro['Creeper'/73, l='MpServer', x=185,63, y=31,00, z=211,50], ro['Creeper'/74, l='MpServer', x=185,50, y=31,00, z=213,63], qc['Chicken'/75, l='MpServer', x=187,69, y=66,00, z=221,44], ro['Creeper'/85, l='MpServer', x=177,31, y=15,00, z=278,66], qc['Chicken'/84, l='MpServer', x=191,56, y=64,00, z=256,59], sb['Spider'/87, l='MpServer', x=178,81, y=21,00, z=280,28], qa['Bat'/86, l='MpServer', x=184,81, y=14,09, z=272,86], ro['Creeper'/81, l='MpServer', x=183,41, y=44,00, z=269,03], bdp['CoCun'/318, l='MpServer', x=175,48, y=69,88, z=218,08], ro['Creeper'/80, l='MpServer', x=184,41, y=44,00, z=267,25], qc['Chicken'/83, l='MpServer', x=190,66, y=64,00, z=264,56], qc['Chicken'/82, l='MpServer', x=178,63, y=64,00, z=268,47], rz['Skeleton'/93, l='MpServer', x=195,50, y=22,00, z=151,50], rz['Skeleton'/95, l='MpServer', x=194,50, y=22,00, z=145,50], rz['Skeleton'/94, l='MpServer', x=197,50, y=26,00, z=139,91], sd['Zombie'/102, l='MpServer', x=193,50, y=32,00, z=171,50], sd['Zombie'/103, l='MpServer', x=192,50, y=32,00, z=172,50], qa['Bat'/849, l='MpServer', x=144,70, y=37,24, z=183,70], rz['Skeleton'/100, l='MpServer', x=207,50, y=40,00, z=154,50], qa['Bat'/101, l='MpServer', x=197,69, y=25,85, z=147,42], qa['Bat'/98, l='MpServer', x=193,78, y=24,47, z=151,17], qa['Bat'/99, l='MpServer', x=202,41, y=25,80, z=155,60], qa['Bat'/96, l='MpServer', x=195,50, y=27,10, z=145,31], qa['Bat'/97, l='MpServer', x=191,18, y=25,67, z=145,19], ro['Creeper'/110, l='MpServer', x=194,72, y=46,00, z=257,94], ro['Creeper'/111, l='MpServer', x=204,66, y=55,00, z=266,50], sd['Zombie'/108, l='MpServer', x=203,13, y=38,00, z=226,56], sd['Zombie'/109, l='MpServer', x=203,13, y=38,00, z=224,41], qa['Bat'/106, l='MpServer', x=196,75, y=40,10, z=225,50], sd['Zombie'/107, l='MpServer', x=204,50, y=38,00, z=227,50], rz['Skeleton'/104, l='MpServer', x=206,50, y=24,00, z=187,50], sd['Zombie'/105, l='MpServer', x=204,13, y=38,00, z=221,59], sb['Spider'/114, l='MpServer', x=192,94, y=35,00, z=294,00], sd['Zombie'/112, l='MpServer', x=196,59, y=23,00, z=297,00], qc['Chicken'/127, l='MpServer', x=220,50, y=67,00, z=203,50], qc['Chicken'/126, l='MpServer', x=227,69, y=65,00, z=212,47], rz['Skeleton'/125, l='MpServer', x=220,66, y=20,00, z=202,78], rz['Skeleton'/124, l='MpServer', x=221,47, y=21,00, z=197,13], ro['Creeper'/123, l='MpServer', x=213,03, y=22,00, z=186,56], rz['Skeleton'/122, l='MpServer', x=212,66, y=21,00, z=188,91], sb['Spider'/121, l='MpServer', x=214,50, y=29,00, z=163,50], rz['Skeleton'/137, l='MpServer', x=216,44, y=53,00, z=277,19], qc['Chicken'/136, l='MpServer', x=222,47, y=65,00, z=237,59], qc['Chicken'/139, l='MpServer', x=213,47, y=65,00, z=258,53], qc['Chicken'/138, l='MpServer', x=219,50, y=65,00, z=267,50], qc['Chicken'/141, l='MpServer', x=223,47, y=64,00, z=277,47], qc['Chicken'/140, l='MpServer', x=223,75, y=64,00, z=271,38], rb['item.item.egg'/142, l='MpServer', x=220,97, y=64,13, z=277,66], qc['Chicken'/129, l='MpServer', x=221,50, y=67,00, z=210,50], qc['Chicken'/128, l='MpServer', x=223,44, y=67,00, z=206,44], qc['Chicken'/131, l='MpServer', x=220,09, y=67,00, z=206,81], qc['Chicken'/130, l='MpServer', x=221,50, y=67,00, z=211,50], qc['Chicken'/133, l='MpServer', x=212,56, y=67,00, z=230,41], qc['Chicken'/132, l='MpServer', x=205,53, y=72,00, z=221,85], qc['Chicken'/135, l='MpServer', x=217,34, y=66,00, z=234,47], rb['item.item.egg'/134, l='MpServer', x=215,91, y=67,13, z=224,75], qc['Chicken'/152, l='MpServer', x=230,44, y=65,00, z=212,47], qc['Chicken'/153, l='MpServer', x=226,38, y=66,00, z=218,47], qc['Chicken'/154, l='MpServer', x=234,28, y=65,00, z=238,34], qc['Chicken'/155, l='MpServer', x=231,59, y=65,00, z=235,47], qc['Chicken'/156, l='MpServer', x=231,63, y=65,00, z=240,44], qc['Chicken'/157, l='MpServer', x=218,59, y=65,00, z=268,59], sd['Zombie'/144, l='MpServer', x=225,66, y=29,00, z=148,69], qc['Chicken'/145, l='MpServer', x=236,47, y=65,00, z=157,53], sd['Zombie'/146, l='MpServer', x=231,50, y=47,00, z=163,50], qc['Chicken'/147, l='MpServer', x=236,50, y=64,00, z=176,50], qc['Chicken'/148, l='MpServer', x=235,31, y=65,00, z=202,16], qc['Chicken'/149, l='MpServer', x=228,47, y=66,00, z=195,63], qc['Chicken'/150, l='MpServer', x=224,41, y=67,00, z=203,38], qc['Chicken'/151, l='MpServer', x=237,47, y=72,00, z=198,53], rz['Skeleton'/171, l='MpServer', x=247,59, y=18,00, z=171,50], rz['Skeleton'/170, l='MpServer', x=245,91, y=18,00, z=167,47], ro['Creeper'/175, l='MpServer', x=249,41, y=16,00, z=180,03], ro['Creeper'/174, l='MpServer', x=248,31, y=16,00, z=178,69], sd['Zombie'/173, l='MpServer', x=254,50, y=52,00, z=171,50], sb['Spider'/172, l='MpServer', x=246,09, y=17,00, z=170,72], qc['Chicken'/186, l='MpServer', x=255,56, y=64,00, z=212,44], qc['Chicken'/187, l='MpServer', x=249,41, y=68,00, z=244,44], qc['Chicken'/184, l='MpServer', x=254,50, y=64,00, z=215,50], qc['Chicken'/185, l='MpServer', x=240,59, y=71,00, z=221,47], qa['Bat'/188, l='MpServer', x=228,71, y=59,05, z=291,82], qc['Chicken'/179, l='MpServer', x=241,88, y=66,00, z=206,16], qc['Chicken'/176, l='MpServer', x=249,41, y=64,00, z=179,53], qc['Chicken'/177, l='MpServer', x=247,53, y=64,00, z=177,56], qc['Chicken'/182, l='MpServer', x=249,44, y=65,00, z=188,56], qc['Chicken'/180, l='MpServer', x=241,19, y=65,00, z=201,78], qc['Chicken'/181, l='MpServer', x=241,94, y=66,00, z=207,09], qc['Chicken'/202, l='MpServer', x=247,50, y=64,00, z=257,59]]
	Retry entities: 0 total; []
Stacktrace:
	at bdm.a(SourceFile:282)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.b(SourceFile:1879)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:533)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)

-- System Details --
Details:
	Minecraft Version: 1.5
	Operating System: Windows 7 (amd64) version 6.1
	Java Version: 1.7.0_07, Oracle Corporation
	Java VM Version: Java HotSpot(TM) 64-Bit Server VM (mixed mode), Oracle Corporation
	Memory: 386269536 bytes (368 MB) / 648740864 bytes (618 MB) up to 954466304 bytes (910 MB)
	JVM Flags: 2 total; -Xms512m -Xmx1024m
	AABB Pool Size: 1726 (96656 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 2 (112 bytes; 0 MB) used
	Suspicious classes: No suspicious classes found.
	IntCache: cache: 0, tcache: 0, allocated: 3, tallocated: 63
	LWJGL: 2.4.2
	OpenGL: GeForce GT 520/PCIe/SSE2 GL version 4.2.0, NVIDIA Corporation
	Is Modded: Probably not. Jar signature remains and client brand is untouched.
	Type: Client (map_client.txt)
	Texture Pack: Default
	Profiler Position: N/A (disabled)
	Vec3 Pool Size: 2805 (157080 bytes; 0 MB) allocated, 12 (672 bytes; 0 MB) used

java.lang.Throwable
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.l(SourceFile:1162)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.K(SourceFile:572)
	at net.minecraft.client.Minecraft.run(SourceFile:524)
	at java.lang.Thread.run(Unknown Source)
--- END ERROR REPORT 7de1a272 ----------

Anon Ymus 2013-03-14T18:23:47Z

I doubt that this is causing the problems, but you may want to update your Java. It's ten versions behind.

Anon Ymus 2013-03-14T18:25:18Z

Sorry, I misunderstood the bug. Confirmed in 13w11a.

Guybrush Threepwood 2013-05-02T20:01:17Z

still there in 13w18b

[Mod] redstonehelper 2015-11-15T17:18:43Z

Fixed in 15w46a.

Anon Ymus 2015-11-15T22:11:59Z

Still exists for multiple-layer snow, but perhaps that is intended.