mojira.dev
MC-118501

Many plants and other blocks behave oddly when blocks are placed on them

Now, usually when you place a block on top of the grass decoration, the grass is removed in favor for the block you placed. This also effects things such as ferns and dead bushes. However, when you try to do the same with a flower, the block goes beside it or on top of it, depending on the location. Expected behaviour would be for the replaced block to break instead, dropping where appropriate.

List of affected blocks:

  • minecraft:dandelion

  • minecraft:poppy

  • minecraft:blue_orchid

  • minecraft:allium

  • minecraft:azure_bluet

  • minecraft:red_tulip

  • minecraft:orange_tulip

  • minecraft:white_tulip

  • minecraft:pink_tulip

  • minecraft:oxeye_daisy

  • minecraft:cornflower

  • minecraft:lily_of_the_valley

  • minecraft:wither_rose

  • minecraft:sunflower

  • minecraft:lilac

  • minecraft:rose_bush

  • minecraft:peony

  • minecraft:wheat

  • minecraft:pumpkin_stem

  • minecraft:attached_pumpkin_stem

  • minecraft:melon_stem

  • minecraft:attached_melon_stem

  • minecraft:beetroots

  • minecraft:carrots

  • minecraft:potatoes

  • minecraft:oak_sapling

  • minecraft:birch_sapling

  • minecraft:spruce_sapling

  • minecraft:jungle_sapling

  • minecraft:acacia_sapling

  • minecraft:dark_oak_sapling

  • minecraft:bamboo_sapling

  • minecraft:sweet_berry_bush

  • minecraft:red_mushroom

  • minecraft:brown_mushroom

  • minecraft:kelp

  • minecraft:tube_coral

  • minecraft:brain_coral

  • minecraft:bubble_coral

  • minecraft:fire_coral

  • minecraft:horn_coral

  • minecraft:tube_coral_fan

  • minecraft:brain_coral_fan

  • minecraft:bubble_coral_fan

  • minecraft:fire_coral_fan

  • minecraft:horn_coral_fan

  • minecraft:tube_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:brain_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:bubble_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:fire_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:horn_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:dead_tube_coral

  • minecraft:dead_brain_coral

  • minecraft:dead_bubble_coral

  • minecraft:dead_fire_coral

  • minecraft:dead_horn_coral

  • minecraft:dead_tube_coral_fan

  • minecraft:dead_brain_coral_fan

  • minecraft:dead_bubble_coral_fan

  • minecraft:dead_fire_coral_fan

  • minecraft:dead_horn_coral_fan

  • minecraft:dead_tube_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:dead_brain_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:dead_bubble_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:dead_fire_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:dead_horn_coral_wall_fan

  • minecraft:sweet_berry_bush

  • minecraft:cobweb

  • minecraft:torch

  • minecraft:wall_torch

  • minecraft:redstone_torch

  • minecraft:redstone_wall_torch

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 5

[Mod] Asteraoth

Confirmed for 1.13.1-pre1

[Mod] Asteraoth

Confirmed for 1.13.1

Confirmed for 18ww50a for dandelion, poppy, blue orchid, allium, azure bluet, all four tulips, oxeye daisy, cornflower, lily of the valley, wither rose, peony, rose bush, lilac, sunflower, both mushrooms, all seven saplings including the bamboo sapling, and sweet berry bushes. Can I request ownership of this ticket?

This is at least as old as 1.8.

Can confirm in 1.19.3

Anthony Watson

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Items

general-breaking-zone, placement, placement-and-support

Minecraft 1.12, Minecraft 1.12.2, Minecraft 17w50a, Minecraft 18w01a, Minecraft 18w02a, ..., 1.17 Pre-release 1, 1.19.3, 1.19.4 Pre-release 1, 1.21.3, 24w45a

Retrieved