mojira.dev
MC-123352

Interaction error with block and GUI, when shift-clicking them with non-block items

The bug

Interacting with / right clicking trapdoors, doors, fence gates and buttons while sneaking / holding shift and holding an item without right click action makes no sound and no arm animation.

How to reproduce

  1. Place a trapdoor, door, fence gate or button

  2. Hold a an item without a right click action, for example an arrow

  3. Shift-click the block you placed

Affected blocks / entity GUIs

Last updated for 17w50a

:blue_star: = Make no sound.
:red_star: = No arm animation.
:green_star: = Make hands or items to bob up and down.

GUI and block types

Behavior in latest version

Shift clicking in 1.12.2 allows interaction

Trapdoor

:blue_star: :red_star:

❌

Door

:blue_star: :red_star:

❌

Fence gate

:blue_star: :red_star:

❌

Button

:blue_star: :red_star:

❌

Lever

:red_star:

❌

Chest

:green_star:

❌

Trapped chest

:green_star:

❌

Ender chest

:green_star:

❌

Shulker box

:green_star:

❌

Crafting table

:green_star:

❌

Furnace

:green_star:

❌

Anvil

:green_star:

❌

Dispenser

:green_star:

❌

Dropper

:green_star:

❌

Enchanting table

:green_star:

❌

Beacon

:green_star:

❌

Brewing stand

:green_star:

❌

Hopper

:green_star:

❌

Light sensor

:red_star:

❌

Redstone repeater

:red_star:

❌

Redstone comparator

:red_star:

❌

Note block

:red_star:

❌

Jukebox

:red_star:

❌

Bed

:red_star:

❌

Horse GUI

:green_star:

✔

Llama GUI

:green_star:

✔

Donkey and mule GUI

:green_star:

✔

Minecart with chest GUI

:green_star:

✔

Minecart with hopper GUI

:green_star:

✔

Minecart with command block GUI

:red_star:

✔

Currently only command block normal operation in the 17w50a.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 5

Cannot confirm for the entity GUIs, for me there is always an arm animation.

I changed the report a little bit, I hope you are fine with that

Also affects 1.13-pre2

How do you change bug reports from other people, Marcono. I did not know how you change descriptions of their bugs although you are not the one who have reported.

Anyway, MC-121798 still affects 1.13-pre4; please update your ticket!

@unknown: Only helpers and moderators can edit other reports. Also, 1.13-pre4 is already listed as an affected version.

[Mod]Les3awe

coschevi

Confirmed

right-click, shift-click

Minecraft 17w50a, Minecraft 18w01a, Minecraft 18w02a, Minecraft 18w03a, Minecraft 18w03b, , Minecraft 18w19b, Minecraft 18w20c, Minecraft 1.13-pre1, Minecraft 1.13-pre2, Minecraft 1.13-pre4

Minecraft 1.13-pre6

Retrieved