[MC-140759] Some of the new village structures are missing a jigsaw block

Some of the new village structures will never generate in your world because they are missing a jigsaw block.

The structures include:

For the plains village:
- minecraft:village/plains/houses/plains_tool_smith_1

For the snowy village:
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_medium_house_1
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_medium_house_2
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_small_house_2
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_small_house_5
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_tannery_1
- minecraft:village/snowy/houses/snowy_masons_house_2

For the savanna village:
- minecraft:village/savanna/savanna_lamp_post_01
- minecraft:village/savanna/houses/savanna_small_house_8
- minecraft:village/savanna/houses/savanna_weaponsmith_2
- minecraft:village/savanna/houses/savanna_mason_1

For desert village:
- minecraft:village/desert/houses/desert_farm_2
- minecraft:village/desert/houses/desert_small_house_8
- minecraft:village/desert/houses/desert_blacksmith_1

For taiga village:
- minecraft:village/taiga/taiga_decoration_1
- ~~minecraft:village/taiga/houses/taiga_armorer_house_2~~
  :info: this one got .../taiga_armorer_2 as replacement as of 19w04a (the old structure file still exists however)
- ~~minecraft:village/taiga/houses/taiga_cartographer_house_1~~
For the zombie desert village:
- minecraft:village/desert/zombie/houses/desert_small_house_8
For the zombie taiga village:
- minecraft:village/taiga/zombie/houses/taiga_armorer_house_2

You can find those structures in these worlds made by slicedlime:

18w49a
18w50a
19w04a
(links are in the description of the video)

Linked issues

relates to 1

MC-140973 Villagers don't spawn in some houses, leading to villages without villagers Resolved

Attachments

Screen Shot 2018-12-13 at 3.51.38 PM.png

Comments 17

Stef B 2018-12-08T15:04:34Z

I added the screenshots. If you can find one of these structures naturally generated in a world then please provide a screenshot, seed and coordinates. Thanks.

Valicon 2018-12-12T21:47:16Z

Confirmed for 18w50a. Additionnal houses are missing a Jigsaw Entrance Block :

For desert village :

desert_blacksmith_1

- desert_small_house_8

For taiga village :

- taiga_cartographer_house_1

Stef B 2018-12-13T14:02:28Z

thanks!

Stef B 2018-12-13T14:15:10Z

Can someone look for missing jigsaw blocks in the outpost structures? I used slicedlime's worlds, so I don't know how to get the actual structure files.

Stef B 2018-12-13T14:17:40Z

i'll add screenshots of the new structures soon!

7 more comments

gaspoweredpick 2018-12-13T22:50:00Z

I actually have seen the desert blacksmith shown in the screenshot (Seed: 255431332495969766 Coordinates: 274 70 -3597)

Stef B 2018-12-14T13:26:37Z

That's actually a weaponsmith, they look the same on the outside but not in the inside. The weaponsmith has a grindstone and a chest, the blacksmith doesn't.

Carlos G. 2018-12-20T06:50:31Z

I am actually doing a Taiga Village/Seed Hunting and so far I noticed that in more than 25 Villages I never found a single Armorer's House or a Cartographer's House, also noticed how common are the Weaponsmith structures, guess is related to a Duplicated File issue.

Stef B 2019-01-09T21:46:12Z

What does comunnity consensus actually mean?

Valicon 2019-01-18T13:18:59Z

Confirmed for 19w03c

Sonicwave 2019-01-18T21:35:25Z

@unknown: Community consensus means that the issue was reproduced by at least one other user (other than the reporter) by commenting or creating a duplicate, while confirmed means it was reproduced by a helper or moderator.

Valicon 2019-01-23T15:51:51Z

Could you relate this issue to MC-140973, please ? Those bugs are both due to missing jigsaw blocks, and the way to fix those is basically add jigsaw blocks

Carlos G. 2019-01-25T01:40:54Z

Can confirm Cartographer's and Armorer Houses are fixed for 19w04 as they now got updated to have the Jigsaw Block that was missing before.

Valicon 2019-01-25T15:59:45Z

taiga_cartographer_house_1 is fixed in the version i'm playing (19w04b)

minecraft:village/savanna/savanna_lamp_post_01 too (it got removed)

Nothing else is fixed

Valicon 2019-01-25T16:12:15Z

In 19w04a, zombie villages were implemented back (only for desert and taiga villages). The following structures of taiga village (zombie version) are missing an entrance jigsaw block :

-taiga_armorer_house_2

Stef B 2019-01-25T20:22:00Z

Updated description for 19w04a/b, I won't add screenshots of the zombie villages, because the structures look exactly the same.

@unknown, that makes sense, thanks!

@unknown, I could still load the lamp post in 04b with a structure block

Valicon 2019-01-25T23:25:11Z

Stef B, its true, you can load the lamp post but it is not in the houses file anymore (my issue was about being or not in house file so i didn't pay attention to that)