[MC-16435] Boats Still Break on Lily's

Sometimes when you hit a lily with a boat, it still will break the boat. (apparently was fixed before)

Attachments

Test.zip

Comments 34

kumasasa 2013-05-25T07:29:02Z

~~Duplicate of MC-2931~~

wobst.michael 2013-09-26T15:51:05Z

Dunno what EvilSeph fixed in 13w39a, but Boats still break when hitting Lily Pads

"Castiel" 2013-09-26T15:56:46Z

Yeah, still broken. How do they test it?

I just put down a bunch of lilypads in a small area of water and went into them on a boat. took about 3-5 hits and broke into sticks and planks

_zombiehunter 2013-09-26T15:58:52Z

Even better: Now both break, the boat AND the lilypads ...

EvilSeph (Warren Loo) 2013-09-26T17:09:35Z

Interesting. Can you show me how you tested this? Was this a newly placed boat?

24 more comments

_zombiehunter 2013-09-26T17:23:19Z

@EvilSeph:
Yes, it was a newly placed boat. Just made a barrier out of lily pads and bumped my boat into it (with full speed). Screenshot: http://i.imgur.com/6yhJiPp.jpg

galaxy_2alex 2013-09-26T17:24:18Z

I can confirm this as well, in an Ocean world with a bunch of Lilipads manually placed and a new boat.

_zombiehunter 2013-09-26T17:25:54Z

The boat doesn't always break, just managed to drive savely through some lily pads ... strange

"Castiel" 2013-09-26T17:26:28Z

Go to pool area in the world (Test.zip) I attached, and place lilypads in there, try crossing to the other side in your boat, boat breaks along with the lilypads

wobst.michael 2013-09-26T17:28:25Z

For me, it happened with a new boat after just two hits (the boat broke when hitting the second Lili Pad)

_zombiehunter 2013-09-26T17:30:41Z

Yep, the number of hits seems to be the reason. Thicker barriers (http://i.imgur.com/rS34lh2.jpg) of lily pads give a practically 100% chance to break the boat (after the boat hits 2-3 lily pads).
Underwater view: http://i.imgur.com/dSgIRIP.jpg

Vaporizer 2013-09-26T17:38:50Z

You can also use this world preset to test it. Just throw down a boat and see how it still breaks.
2;1,20x9,111;1;village

"Castiel" 2013-09-26T17:42:33Z

Attached screenshots as well, little awkward but it should make sense

_zombiehunter 2013-09-26T17:46:51Z

@Vaporizer:
Nice preset, very funny. Interesting detail: Empty boats never seem to break. Only with players in it ...
Empty boats can destroy any number of lily pads: http://i.imgur.com/jOmWxzt.jpg

"Castiel" 2013-09-26T17:49:10Z

I have discovered not holding down "w" (pressing it for half a second every so often) doesn't affect the boat breaking at all, and it just glides through the lilypads.

EvilSeph (Warren Loo) 2013-09-26T18:32:20Z

I see. I didn't test with such an extreme case. I believe I've fixed it now, thanks!

"Castiel" 2013-09-26T18:38:19Z

No, thank you for fixing it <3

Bud Gillett 2013-09-26T20:46:55Z

Yes... I find that boats still break on lily pads

Bud Gillett 2013-09-26T20:47:21Z

Thanks Seph!

"Castiel" 2013-09-27T12:36:14Z

39b, still breaks, but seems to only break at 5th lilypad? attached screenshot of aftermath of testing

Edit: I can't count, it's 4th

EvilSeph (Warren Loo) 2013-09-27T17:18:50Z

I have not pushed my fix yet, so the fix is not in 39b, sorry.

galaxy_2alex 2013-09-27T17:19:55Z

Does this mean a 'c' this week again? Dinnerbone would definitely like it 😛

_zombiehunter 2013-09-27T17:21:09Z

@EvilSeph:
In this case, you may correct the "Fix Version/s" tag to "Future version ..." 🙂

G A 2013-10-22T17:32:56Z

Bug still present in 1.7 pre-release, swamps are almost impossible to navigate without breaking and lilypads placed in a row are a boat destroyer.

eleazzaar 2013-10-27T00:35:54Z

NOT Resolved.

Boats still break on lilies and other silly things (like chickens) in 1.7.2.

Sp4rkle 2013-11-02T17:46:54Z

Unresolved.

Boats still break on some lily pads on various impacts (slow - fast). Occurrence is random, but happens more often than not. 1.7.2

eleazzaar 2013-11-02T18:25:24Z

It seems the likelihood of wrecking the boat has to do with the speed. My boat seems to survive most very slow collisions.

Phillip Susi 2014-03-28T17:42:15Z

This is NOT a duplicate of MC-2931.

Fenhl (Max Dominik Weber) 2014-04-03T20:16:11Z

Affects 14w11b and not a duplicate of MC-2931. Please reopen.

Itouch2 2014-04-30T11:16:15Z

Confirmed for 14w17a and 14w18a

Itouch2 2014-05-11T10:20:04Z

Confirmed for 14w19a.

Vaporizer 2014-07-11T14:30:15Z

This still happens in 14w28b, you can use this preset to easily test it:
3;minecraft:bedrock,20*minecraft:water,minecraft:waterlily;0;

Also, this shouldn't be duplicated by MC-2931.

Jeremy 2015-03-19T20:46:37Z

Confirmed for 1.8.3.

Dlawso the Really Lucky Rabbit 2015-10-08T17:30:41Z

Fixed in 15w41b, according to MC-90085