mojira.dev
MC-172084

Soul Sand and Soul Soil have no sounds

The bug

I found that soul sand and soul soil do not make noise when either broken, placed, or walked on.

Linked issues

MC-172091 soul soil and soul sand do not have sounds Resolved MC-172122 the soulsand and the soul soil have no sound Resolved MC-172140 Soul soul has no sound. Resolved MC-172206 Breaking Soul Sand in 20w07a doesn't have sound anymore Resolved MC-172232 Soul soil doesn't make any noises in the newest snapshot Resolved

Attachments

Comments 5

For some reason, the sound events for soul sand and soul soil got renamed to use _ instead of . (as seen on burger). For instance, block.soul_sand.break was changed to block.soul_sand_break. All other blocks were left unchanged (burger). The names for those events in sounds.json were not changed, although sounds.json was updated between the assets index last week and this week's. It used to be this, and now is this; although it was updated, that was only to add piglin and hoglin sounds and the snow golem shear sound (MC-94094).

I don't know why they renamed the sound events for soul sand and soul soil; it doesn't seem like a logical change and probably should just be reverted to fix this issue.

Would be better if they fixed the sound files themselves, it's best if the sound event names are correct.

I made a temporary fix for this. I attached it to the post, but accidentally attached it twice. (Since I thought dragging it over would attach it to my own post, and it didn't work so I tried again and then noticed after that it was being put on the main post)
If a moderator could remove one I'd appreciate it.
Basically it's a simple sounds.json fix to make it play the other sound events for now, until Mojang fixes the blocks to use the correct sound events.

Samson Thornhill

slicedlime

Confirmed

Very Important

Sound

soil_soil, soul_sand

20w07a, 20w08a

20w09a

Retrieved