When a banner with a design is placed down, then the pick block key is used on it, the game creates a new banner in the player's inventory (while in creative) and this new banner (with the same design as the original banner) does not stack with the original banner.
EDIT: See comments for information on how to reproduce.
Related issues
Attachments
Comments
migrated
galaxy_2alex
Did you use regular pick block, or Ctrl + pick block?
migrated
Hi Galaxy_2Alex!
I used regular pick block. I am running a few tests now and will get back in a few minutes with the results.
Thanks!
migrated
Hello, I've tested this a bit more with different versions and conversions and I now can say that any banner created in 1.15.2 and pick-blocked in 1.16 Release Candidate 1 creates a new banner.
You can test this out for yourself by creating a world in 1.15.2, creating a banner with something on it, updating that world to 1.16 release candidate 1 (or at least prerelease 4, but possibly even earlier) and then placing down your banner and pick-block-ing (I don't really know the correct verb 😛) it. The game should create a brand new item in the player's inventory.
[Mod] markderickson
Hey there!
I just tested this in my world. I got the same results; however, when making a new banner in 1.16, it stacks with the banner created by pick-blocking the original banner. This also means that any banner created in 1.15 will not stack with any banners from 1.16, even if it has the same design.
This probably should be fixed soon (if possible).
[Mod] markderickson
Hi there!
Can confirm for 20w27a. If it will get fixed, it should probably be fixed soon, or else there is pretty much no point in fixing it (it only affects banners created before 1.16).
[Mod] Jingy
Is this issue still valid? It has since fallen out of relevance to the latest editions of the game, and therefore is not reproducable in the new versions.
[Mod] Jingy
Affects 1.20.1
j_p_smith
@@unknown Which version are you upgrading from? I'm not managing to reproduce this in 1.20.1. What NBT does your banner (item form) have before and after upgrading?
[Mod] Jingy
I should have been more specific, my apologies. This issue does not seem to apply to banners with either just a color, or banners with a color and pattern anymore. It does however effect blank banners that have been "pick block'ed" (and thus, have NBT despite having no real difference from a regular banner)
Shown here, the top row is 1.15.2, and the bottom row/stacked items are ones from 1.20.1. Banners with patterns and/or colors stack as expected, but the blank pick-block white banner does not.
[media]
migrated
Per the reporter's comment (second oldest comment), this is about regular pick block, not NBT pick block.
[Mod] Jingy
After testing the issue properly, I can't reproduce it either. The banners stack as expected. Sorry for the confusion 😛