mojira.dev
MC-2292

OS X: Ctrl modifier key instead of Cmd

On OS X, when you want to paste text in the game (e.g: the seed field, a server IP, the multiplayer chat... any text field), you have to use the shortcut Ctrl-V.
It's perfectly logical on Windows or Linux, but on OS X, all the programs use the Cmd-V shortcut, so it's not intuitive at all.

Linked issues

Comments

Pixelgraph

I found this pretty annoying, I had to get used to it, though it's odd to copy a seed CMD-C then go CTRL-V in Minecraft.

Cronos Dage

No such thing as "Mac OS X" Mountain Lion. It's "OS X." I'd advise modifying your ticket to reflect this.

Edit: Thanks for fixing this.

James Clarke

This isn't the only issue - the following all exist (some aren't OS X specific):

The following system-wide OS X text-editing shortcuts do not exist:

  • Cmd+A/C/V/X - should be instead of Ctrl+A/C/V/X

  • Option/Alt+Left/Right - should move back and forth by word (like Ctrl on Windows)

  • Cmd+Left/Right - should be the equivalent of Home/End

  • (extension of above) Cmd+Shift+Left/End - should select everything before/after the cursor

  • Cmd+Backspace - should delete everything before the cursor

  • Alt+Backspace - should delete the word before the cursor

System-independent issues (not just OS X):

  • Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right - only selects one word

  • Ctrl+Right - should 'hug' the word rather than jumping past the trailing space.

Reasons why the code does what it does:

You include Cmd as a recognised alternative to Ctrl, but a lot of the key combinations you listen out for are detected by their C0 code, which of course will only include the Ctrl character.

Jesper the End

confirmed for 13w18c
I don't see why this isn't fixed yet. It doesn't seem to be so hard to fix.
(correct me if I'm wrong, I do not program java)

Torabi

Hmm... According to Grum:

1) Anything that use CTRL before now exclusively uses CMD on osx. (Meaning the default stack-drop-keybinding will quit your game 😃)

This should have been fixed with 1.6.2. Guess he missed something.

Moe

Yeah, it's still not working for me. I still HAVE to use CTRL instead of CMD, and it's is very annoying. Edit: I am on 1.6.2

a

Still in 14w11b
The issue fixed in MC-13695 is not the same as this issue.

James Fields

Not fixed in 1.7.4. Although technically Mac users can press CTRL+V, not only is it an oddity for the operating system, I have a gaming keyboard that allows me to program text macros that are "sent" to the application using copy & paste. The keybaord control software sends "CMD+V" to paste, which is proper for a Mac, but Minecraft doesn't recognize it.

Ezekiel

Yeah, I have that same issue

a

14w18a

a

Still have this in 14w33a.

a

14w34b.

Naor Volkovich

Finally it got fixed! Thanks you, Grum!!!

Erik Broes

Cmd-AXCV are what we 'supported' for those commands. Those are using 'Cmd' now on OSX.

a

Thank you.
Quick question, when you use the Cut/Copy function, but nothing is selected, the clipboard is still cleared/made blank. Is that normal for Minecraft?

John Scott

Depends. Does that happen when you use other programs? If yes, then it's normal. If not, file a bug on this Minecraft bug tracker.

a

No. Standard cut/copy behavior on OS X requires an explicit selection to update the clipboard.
I'll create the report: MC-68497

Baptiste Candellier

I'm glad my bug report got fixed, even though I don't use a Mac anymore... 😛 Thanks, Grum!

kumasasa

According to MC-78815 this was not fixed for pasting in signs.

a

Ok, well the mod on MC-78815 marked it as an invalid feature request. I'd like to see a Won't Fix or WAI from Mojang though...
Pasting on signs does not exist in 1.8.7

Baptiste Candellier

Erik Broes

Confirmed

OSX, controls, keyboard, mac, paste, shortcuts

Minecraft 1.4.3, Minecraft 1.4.6, Minecraft 1.4.7, Minecraft 1.5, Minecraft 1.5.1, ..., Minecraft 14w33a, Minecraft 14w33c, Minecraft 14w34a, Minecraft 14w34b, Minecraft 14w34c

Minecraft 14w34d

Retrieved