[MC-2356] Statistics Menu shows impossible combinations for survival

The statistics menu show numbers in wrong columns for blocks and items that cannot be either crafted, or used in survival mode. Portals are shown as having been used 171 times. Coal is shown having been created 6,024 times (yes coal, not charcoal). Ink sacks are shown as having been created 321 times (not possible.) The only explanation I can think of is possibly using time spent on the creative inventory as legitimate ways to obtain this data?

Attachments

Comments 19

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-05T21:17:21Z

Screen grabs of the statistics menu. The columns are: times crafted, times used, and times mined for blocks, and times depleted, times crafted, and times used for items.

Oliver Okum 2012-11-06T15:31:22Z

Please reread the statistics window. Inksacs have been used 321 times by yourself, they've not been created 😉

-> Close please, as its not a bug.

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-06T18:23:42Z

No, that is in the times crafted column. You can't craft ink sacs.

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-06T19:49:03Z

So, as stated, the columns are Crafted - Used - Mined
So inksacs in your screenshot is showing:
Crafted = -
Used = 321
Mined = 706

Perfectly fine.

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-06T23:34:07Z

I show you another picture, the middle column for the items is clearly marked "Times crafted"

9 more comments

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-07T00:17:46Z

I'm still not getting this. But the columns are different between Blocks and Items.

Blocks = Crafted - Used - Mined
Items = Depleted - Crafted - Used

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-09T00:50:57Z

Marking as working as intended for now, unless it can be proven that the statistics window is in fact faulty. If so, it can be revisited then.

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-09T01:29:27Z

So you think this just might be a glitch on my computer?

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-09T01:57:36Z

I just can't quite see the issue from the screenshots. The columns on the blocks and items stats windows are different.

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-09T03:26:27Z

Ok, so I accidentally added the screenshot for the blocks, which I've removed. Coal and ink sacs are showing up under the crafting column, and you can't craft either of those items. I don't know why they are showing up under there, unless selecting the item from the creative inventory is somehow being registered as the crafting of an item, which could explain why it is being placed in that column.

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-12T19:17:47Z

The game code handles charcoal and coal in the same code. Charcoal is defined as damaged coal. When I crafted some charcoal in the furnace, the items page showed a new entry for "coal".

Dye appears to be much the same. So where you see an Ink Sac, it in fact represents ALL dyes. Can you confirm that no other dyes exist on your items page?

Brandon Bourgeois 2012-11-12T23:22:38Z

Interesting, and I actually do not have any other dyes on the items page, which makes this even more bizarre.

Chalmes (Jon) 2012-11-12T23:25:18Z

Am going to re-open as I believe the issue is that items which use the damage value to determine their type do not show correctly on the statistics screens.

Tails 2013-03-15T03:12:39Z

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

kumasasa 2013-07-23T20:42:56Z

No answer, assuming no longer an issue.

branza 2013-09-16T13:26:35Z

This is still happening in 13w37b, the items that use damage values to determine their type are shown as one single item.

FaRo1 2016-02-10T19:39:04Z

Minecraft clearly tells me that I have crafted 5.538 ink sacs. And 1.357 cooked chicken, 358 cooked steak, 107 cooked mutton, 13 cooked porkchop and 55 stone, . Also I have "0" and "~~", where "0" is sorted over "~~".
Also I am supposed to have "used" 210 ink sacs, (155 water bottles, which I strongly believe to be too high and 112 "item.splash_potion.name", displaying as a splash water bottle, which I have never used).
These stats are obviously wrong, I just don't know the reason why.

branza 2016-02-10T21:38:40Z

@@unknown There are two things that aren't intuitive about the statistics:

"Crafting" includes things like smelting and brewing potions.
The items actually represent all items that have the same ID, but different damage values. All dyes are actually one single item, but with different damage values for the different colors. So the 5.538 ink sacs also include all the other colors that you've crafted. Similarly, the water bottles include all the potions.

FaRo1 2016-02-11T10:43:15Z

Ok, but then the bug is in the other direction, because I have cooked at least 10 stacks of stone.