mojira.dev
MC-236746

Most plants are listed as minecraft:mineable/axe, despite being mined faster other tools

Most plants are listed as minecraft:mineable/axe, despite being mined faster other tools.

 

Plant

Current Mineable Tag

Fastest Tool

grass

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

tall_grass

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

fern

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

large_fern

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

dead_bush

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

bamboo

mineable/axe

Sword

sugar_cane

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

carrots

mineable/axe

Hoe

potatoes

mineable/axe

Hoe

wheat

mineable/axe

Hoe

beetroots

mineable/axe

Hoe

vine

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

glow_lichen

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

twisting_vines

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

twisting_vines_plant

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

weeping_vines

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

weeping_vines_plant

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

cave_vines

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

cave_vines_plant

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

small_dripleaf

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

large_dripleaf

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

lily_pad

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

spore_blossom

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

nether_wart

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

#flowers

mineable/axe

Hoe/Shears

 

 

Attachments

Comments 3

Bamboo, lichen, and dripleaves are mined faster with axes, so there is no problem there. All the other plants are mined instantly, so there is no problem there.

Requesting a sword/shears tag is a feature request (MC-225465)

I'd say there is a problem with the instantly mined plants: why are they in the tag in the first place if they're always mined instantly? The tag solely exists to configure what tool increases mining speed, so their inclusion in this case is completely redundant.

1.18-pre5;fixes the flowers case by removing them from this tag, so I don't see how this is still considered a feature request.

ic22487

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

1.17.1, 21w37a

Retrieved