mojira.dev
MC-249663

The subtitles of some parrot imitation sounds are inconsistent with the original sounds' subtitles

The Bug:

The subtitles of some parrot imitation sounds are inconsistent with the original sounds' subtitles.

Below, I've constructed a table that highlights these inconsistencies.

Hostile Entity

Subtitle of Ambient Sound

 Subtitle of Parrot-Imitated Sound

Notes

Blaze

Blaze breathes

Parrot breathes

 

Cave Spider

Spider hisses

Parrot hisses

While the parrot-imitated subtitle here is correct, the original ambient subtitle of cave spiders isn't. This issue is currently being tracked at MC-98316.

Creeper

N/A

Parrot hisses

 

Drowned

Drowned gurgles

Parrot gurgles

 

Elder Guardian

Elder Guardian moans

Parrot flaps

The correct subtitle here for this parrot-imitated sound would be "Parrot moans".

Ender Dragon

Dragon roars

Parrot roars

 

Endermite

Endermite scuttles

Parrot scuttles

 

Evoker

Evoker murmurs

Parrot murmurs

 

Ghast

Ghast cries

Parrot cries

 

Guardian

Guardian moans

Parrot moans

 

Hoglin

Hoglin growls

Parrot growls

 

Husk

Husk groans

Parrot groans

 

Illusioner

Illusioner murmurs

Parrot murmurs

 

Magma Cube

Magma Cube squishes

Parrot squishes

 

Phantom

Phantom screeches

Parrot screeches

 

Piglin

Piglin snorts

Parrot snorts

 

Piglin Brute

Piglin Brute snorts

Parrot snorts mightily

The correct subtitle here for this parrot-imitated sound would be "Parrot snorts".

Pillager

Pillager murmurs

Parrot murmurs

 

Ravager

Ravager grunts

Parrot grunts

 

Shulker

Shulker lurks

Parrot lurks

 

Silverfish

Silverfish hisses

Parrot hisses

 

Skeleton

Skeleton rattles

Parrot rattles

 

Slime

Slime squishes

Parrot squishes

 

Spider

Spider hisses

Parrot hisses

 

Stray

Stray rattles

Parrot rattles

 

Vex

Vex vexes

Parrot vexes

 

Vindicator

Vindicator mutters

Parrot mutters

 

Warden

Warden whines

Parrot roars

The correct subtitle here for this parrot-imitated sound would be "Parrot whines".

Witch

Witch giggles

Parrot giggles

 

Wither

Wither angers

Parrot angers

 

Wither Skeleton

Wither Skeleton rattles

Parrot rattles

 

Zoglin

Zoglin growls

Parrot growls

 

Zombie

Zombie groans

Parrot groans

 

Zombie Villager

Zombie Villager groans

Parrot groans

 

h3. Steps to Reproduce:

  • Ensure that you have subtitles enabled in your accessibility settings.

  • Produce any of the affected sounds as listed above and watch your subtitles overlay closely.

  • Take note as to whether or not the subtitles of some parrot imitation sounds are inconsistent with the original sounds' subtitles.

Observed Behavior:

Some parrot imitation subtitles are inconsistent with the original sounds' subtitles.

Expected Behavior:

All parrot imitation subtitles would be consistent with the original sounds' subtitles.

Comments 3

Can confirm.

Also might want to add MC-249661 to the notes for the Warden.

Wouldn't it make more sense for "snorts mightily" to be kept for distinction's sake?

It would, it would be better if it both matched and was distinct (piglin brute's subtitle changed).

Avoma

Erik Broes

Community Consensus

Low

Accessibility

22w12a, 22w13a, 22w14a, 22w15a

22w16a

Retrieved