So I was mining and i turn the corner and there is grass and flowers on the dirt! I was mining at layer 20 and this was there
Linked issues
is duplicated by 17
MC-9807
Flowers Spawn Underground
Resolved
MC-30397
Double Tallgrass spawned in a ravine
Resolved
MC-31157
Flowers spawning in light 0
Resolved
MC-47590
Flowers spawn in caves
Resolved
MC-87527
grass in caves
Resolved
MC-148259
Blue orchid found in cave
Resolved
MC-148851
Flowers can generate in caves under a Flower Forest
Resolved
MC-205437
Generated dandelions in cave
Resolved
MC-214925
peony spawning in cves
Resolved
MC-226591
Flowers in cave
Resolved
MC-230524
Flowers generate in caves
Resolved
MC-235244
Plants are generate underground.
Resolved
MC-235887
Generation error
Resolved
MC-236668
tall flowers spawn inside caves on top of the grass if there was flower forest biome above
Resolved
MC-236773
Grass appearing in caves
Resolved
MC-236899
Tall Grass on Dirt in Caves
Resolved
MC-237533
Grass and flowers generate under cliff (0 sky light)
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 13
Also this could always happen. I've come across it since 1.4.2. Dirt blocks (and grass blocks) have a chance of spawning grass no matter where there are (surface or not). The code doesn't destinguish between surface or cave for them.
see the Trivia on the wiki
http://www.minecraftwiki.net/wiki/Grass
I can confirm this (for grass) in 13w37b.
Seed:
2843157688691860621
Coordinates:
-50, 12, 267
A screenshot of the bug, note the coordinates. There's a lava pit nearby so this may relate to MC-9807
I don't see this as an issue... In fact, I'd like to see MORE flora underground, personally.
I'm neutral on the matter. On one hand, it'd be nice to see some variation underground (and it'd help make landmarks for navigation), but on the other hand, it's interesting to see the underground as this barren, lifeless and hostile place. Even the Nether has friendly (well, usually) mobs.
It's also possible this is Works as Intended (as MC-9807 implies), but I find it odd as it's generating tall grass on a dirt (not grass) block.
it is pretty odd, but it makes sense to an extent. It could be argued that a few stray seeds were brought in by some of the bats, and grew out of guano near lava.
Which would make sense if there was all of the following:
A) Any way to access the cave from the surface
B) Bats
C) Water
Maybe then, but not otherwise.
Unsurprisingly, this carries on to 13w38c.
[media]Seed: -6104811593248799588/tp -200 17 318
As far as I'm concerned, this is not related to MC-9807. As you can see from my screenshot, there is a lava lake nearby, and there's light behind my character. However, the light behind my character is from where I dug down and broke through, and the lava lake is too far away. The light level (bl and sl) on the dirt blocks containing grass is 0.
Light level aside, this should be considered unintended, even for MC-9807. Tall Grass and Double Tall Grass should only be generated on top of grass blocks, not dirt blocks.
That won't bothers me, why not? XD
The cave was completely dark when the flower generated.
I'm experiencing the same bug even in 1.7
but it has been in the game since forever
Djfe are you readed this?
Status: Resolved
Resolution: Works As Intended
Please take a screenshot by pressing F2 and attach it so we can see.
Also, providing the seed and coordinates (press F3) would help especially.