mojira.dev
MC-45619

Water, Signs, Vines, Torches etc. in the same block as item frame break item frame's redstone signal

The bug

When a block shares a block space with an item frame, the comparator cannot detect the rotation of the item in the frame.

To reproduce

  1. Place an item frame with an item inside it and a comparator behind the block it's on.

  2. Place one of the affected blocks, for example a torch, in the same block as the item frame.

  3. Turn the item
    → The comparator turns off

Linked issues

MC-45949 Signs disrupt item frame comparator output MC-48310 Itemframe redstone signal not updating/outputting when torch placed on same block as the frame MC-48652 Comparator doesn't give an output from a item frame if a button exist in the same block. MC-51547 Vines, Torches Etc. Break Comparator / Item Frames Redstone Signal MC-67359 Item frame comparator not outputting if frame on same block with torch MC-92400 comparator no signal MC-111367 Item Frames Do Not Send Comparator Signals When Submerged MC-123437 Redstone comparator does not detect item frame MC-133837 Item in item frame not detected by comparator if across from a sign or banner MC-136081 Item frames do not activate comparator when placed underwater MC-136172 Waterlogged item frames don't work with comparators. MC-138682 Comparators not taking redstonesignal of itemframes, that are underwater MC-158207 Redstone Comparator isn't working with frames, when there's torch on frame. MC-159064 Item frames not powering comparators when placed in the same block as a trapdoor MC-164372 Comparator not recognizing item frames when in blocks

Attachments

Comments

Deleted account

Is this still a concern in the current Minecraft version 14w20b / Launcher version 1.3.11 or later? If so, please update the affected versions in order to best aid Mojang ensuring bugs are still valid in the latest releases/pre-releases.

Britton McLeavy

This posts issue seems to be solved as of Snapshot 14w25b, but the issue with it not outputting signal of an item's angle in the item frame with a block such as a button, torch, vine, or ladder is still an issue as of 14w25b. The post said as duplicates explain this in more detail.

PsychoLynx

Still affects 1.8 pre-2

PsychoLynx

Unsurprisingly, affects 1.8 also.

PsychoLynx

Still affects 1.8.2-pre4

PsychoLynx

Affects 1.8.4. Gah.

PsychoLynx

Affects 1.8.6 - how am I ever going to get my secret torch passageway working at this rate :s

Draktharis

Affects 1.8.8 and 15w32c.

Draktharis

Affects 15w50a.

PsychoLynx

Affects 1.9-Pre 2 :/

SunCat

Confirmed for 1.9

SunCat

Still in 1.9.1-pre3

SunCat

Still in 16w15b

PsychoLynx

Affects 1.9.3-pre1

vilhalmer

Still affecting 1.9.4

PsychoLynx

Affects 16w32b. Some day my bugfix will come...

11people5

Confirmed for Minecraft 1.12

muzikbike

Affects 18w22c

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre1

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre2

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre3

muzikbike

Affects 1.13-pre4

Zachary Suwalski

Confirmed for 1.13.1-pre1.

20Attila03

1.14 first 2 snapshots: same

muzikbike

Tested with difficulty in 19w05a

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 19w08b

muzikbike

Also blocked by MC-154499 in 1.14.3-pre3

muzikbike

No longer blocked in 1.14.3-pre4

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.3, 1.14.4-pre1, and 1.14.4-pre2

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4-pre3

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4-pre4

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4-pre5

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4-pre6

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4-pre7

Zachary Suwalski

Affects 1.14.4

PsychoLynx

Glad to see this is finally assigned after "some" waiting 😃

Claudio Gaete

muzikbike

Felix Jones

Confirmed

Redstone

comparator, item_frame

Minecraft 14w04a, Minecraft 14w32d, Minecraft 1.8-pre2, Minecraft 1.8, Minecraft 1.8.1, ..., 1.15 Pre-release 6, 1.15 Pre-release 7, 1.15.1 Pre-release 1, 1.15.2 Pre-Release 1, 1.15.2 Pre-release 2

20w06a

Retrieved