mojira.dev
MC-8184

Redstone block and torches don't power dispensers, droppers, TNT and Noteblocks

Dispensers and droppers will not be activated by either redstone blocks or redstone torches.
They do get activated by other sources.

I placed TNT down and then a redstone torch next to it, on the same level.

What I expected to happen was
TNT blows up.

What actually happened was
The TNT did not ignite, but when I triggered a block update of the torch (by placing another torch next to the original and diagonally from the TNT), it did ignite.

How to replicate
1) Place TNT on a flat area of ground
2) Place a redstone torch or block adjacent to the TNT - even on all 4 sides.
3) Note that the TNT does not ignite.
4) Place a torch next to the original(s) (but not a block, this will not trigger an update) Relative position to the TNT does not matter upon further testing
5) Note that the TNT now ignites.

How this should be fixed
Ensure that TNT receives block updates from redstone torches and blocks as soon as they are placed, instead of waiting for them to send one. This does not occur with doors or pistons, which are also redstone-activated device, so something has not been copied over.

Linked issues

MC-8223 Tnt doesnt light with redstonetorch next to it. Resolved MC-8241 Dispenser with tnt Resolved MC-8248 Redstone torches do not power dispensers in any way, but Do power Droppers Resolved MC-8287 TNT doesn't always activate when activated with redstone. Resolved MC-8298 redstone block with sticky pistons dont activate TNT Resolved

Attachments

Comments 22

...and TNT.

Noteblocks.

I found out that if you place 2 torches beside the TNT and break one of them that the TNT will ignite.

@Tails maybe everything which can be powered by redstone πŸ™‚

No actually, pistons, command blocks, any kind of doors work for some reason...

12 more comments
Jared Jeyaretnam

Once again. Make this 12w07a. And get this fixed, Dinnerbone, this is a major problem! One of the ways most people set off TNT is through redstone torches, not flint and steel.

I can confirm in 13w07a.

Confirmed in 13w07a

I added another pic. the bottom doesn't update eather.

Jared Jeyaretnam

ffs Dinnerbone, hurry up and fix this before 1.5!

Mustek

Jens Bergensten

Confirmed

Snapshot 13w04a, Snapshot 13w05a, Snapshot 13w05b, Snapshot 13w06a, Snapshot 13w07a, Snapshot 13w09a, Snapshot 13w09b, Snapshot 13w09c

Snapshot 13w10a

Retrieved