mojira.dev
MC-88847

Upside-down Stairs are messed up.

Stairs will auto align when in placed in a corner so that they look nicer with other stairs placed next to them. At 15w38a the alignment no longer works for stairs that are upside-down. When placing the block attempts to align with other stairs but does so in an incorrect fashion.

After trying out old saves with corner upside-down stairs, I found that they too look out of place. So, as I understand it; it has to do with the rendering of the blockstate and not due to error in the placement code that chooses the blockstate.

After further testing. I found that the selection box (the block out line that appears when cursor is pointed at the block) is also behaving funnily. So I tested the collision of the block by firing arrows at it to determine better where the block starts and stops. The rendering/collision is indeed off. Arrows would collide on portions of the block that were rendered as "air" and pass through portions rendered as "block". After trying this out I found out all the upside down stairs now have collision error.

I found that any upside-down stairs (not just cornered ones) had collision errors.

Related issues

MC-88873 Stairs texture broken in 15w38a MC-88874 Stairs don't bend in the right directions. MC-88885 there is block data for stairs and obsidian MC-88902 Stairs hitbox is incorrect MC-88916 the angles of stairs if positioned in the roof not connect well with each other MC-88938 Upside down stairs show wrong model MC-89009 Upside down stairs broken MC-89049 Stairs hitbox is rotated MC-89058 Purpur upsidedown stair models incorrectly referenced! MC-89061 Upside Down Corner Stair Places Wrong MC-89063 Bug Upstairs MC-89080 This bug is a really issue with the upside down couch stair trick. MC-89102 Glitchy Stairs MC-89118 Upside-down corner stairs are incorrectly orientated. MC-89155 upside-down stairs MC-89157 Bug with the stairs MC-89160 Upside down stairs behave in a strange way in 15w38b MC-89223 Upside-down stairs corner bad model MC-89224 Wrong model on stairs MC-89225 Upside-down Stairs Not Transforming Correctly on Corners MC-89233 Stairs Bending Around and In Corners MC-89236 wrong stair texture / model MC-89313 Hitboxes for upside down stairs reversed. MC-89317 Upside down stairs MC-89320 Upside Down Stairs Not Connecting Correctly MC-89325 Upside down stairs not connecting in corners MC-89338 hitbox and display of stairs is inaccurate under certain placement. MC-89345 The stairs can't be placed correctly in snapshot 15w39c MC-89348 Upside down stairs in corner are placed 90 degree wrong. MC-89356 Upside down Stairs placed on corners don't connect properly MC-89366 Upside down corner blocks not forming correctly MC-89375 Stair connection bug. MC-89384 upsidedown stairs don't connect propperly MC-89395 upside down stairs are broken wen they are in the angle MC-89411 Upside down stairs do not connect properly. MC-89419 15w39c Upside Down Stairs MC-89449 bad stairs hitbox MC-89458 Stairs bug MC-89493 Corner Stairs Messed Up When Upside-Down MC-89545 Stair Connection Bug MC-89566 Downwards Corner Stairs block models are buggy MC-89607 Upside down "corner" Stairs change states after relaunch MC-89632 Stairs

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media]
migrated

Since the stairs were upside-down I could not walk on them. So I though firing arrows would be the best way to test collision.

migrated

Confirm this happens with all types of stair blocks in new and saved worlds.

migrated

Confirmed.

migrated

No joy in 15w38b.

migrated

Confirmed, stairs are wrong when put upside down...

migrated

Confirmed for 38b

migrated

This is true. I really do not like this,

[Mod]Les3awe

This makes the staircase becomes ugly 😞

[Mod]Les3awe

Confirmed for 15w39b

[Mod]Les3awe

Confirmed for 15w39c

migrated

Can also confirm for 15w39c

migrated

It does make the stairs ugly. Maybe 15w40a will fix it.

migrated

This issue has returned in 15w42a

EDIT: My error, pre-15w40 blockstate file in resource pack. Disregard.

migrated

@unknown: Not for me. Please attach some screenshots of the messed up stairs with the F3 screen open.

migrated

Erik Broes

Confirmed

Minecraft 15w38a, Minecraft 15w38b, Minecraft 15w39b, Minecraft 15w39c

Minecraft 15w40a

Retrieved