mojira.dev
MC-93281

Missing sound events for multiple blocks and items

The bug

Some blocks and entities don't play any sounds in at least one of the following conditions:

  • Placing them

  • Breaking them

  • Walking on them. Fixed for every previous instances found (comment if you find any new).
    For bug report of walking on shulker boxes and boats, see MC-101950

  • Using them, i.e. right-clicking them, with different items

Affected blocks, entities and items

:info: Lists below may be incomplete

Blocks

  • Placing plants in Flower Pots (see

[media]
  • for fix)

Entities

  • Boats (MC-93059)

  • All Minecarts

  • End Crystals

Additional (using items, blocks & entities, not placing)

  • Using Spawn Eggs

  • Putting/taking out Music Disc in/from Jukebox

  • Dying sheep or pets' collars

  • Fertilizing with Bone Meal

  • Changing Redstone Repeater delay

  • Changing Daylight Detector mode

  • Putting food on Campfire

  • Feeding breedable mobs (except cats, horses, donkeys, llamas, pandas & foxes). Also giving bones to wolves

  • Putting name tag on mobs

  • Eating cake

  • Opening Chest in Minecart

  • Making animals sit

  • Entering a bed also doesn't make a sound, despite this changing the occupied block state to true

  • Certain projectiles don't have sounds when they collide with something (i.e. eggs, snowballs, ender pearls)

Fixed cases as of 19w45b

Blocks: Signs, Banners, all Skulls, Lily Pads, Redstone, Nether Warts, Carrots*, Potatoes*, Seeds*, Beetroot Seeds*, Melon Seeds*, Pumpkin Seeds*, Cocoa beans** 

Items: Item Frames, Paintings, Leads

Additional: Placing armor in Armor Stands, placing Eyes of Ender in End Portal Frames, Water Buckets, Lava Buckets

  • Fixed in 19w03a

    • Fixed in 19w14b

Related issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media]
migrated

Is this list complete? If you collect the other "missing sound" tickets here we can resolve them all to this one ticket.

[Mod]Les3awe

Can confirm.

[Mod]Les3awe

Also affect Redstone / Painting.

migrated

I don't have any music... =/

migrated

@@unknown: See MC-91803.

migrated

BTW, if someone's interested, a guy called Onnowhere made a command block contraption that add these sounds into the game in 1.8 Check his YouTube channel.

SteveKunG

Hi. I have attached some fix when placing plant into the flower pot. (Using 1.8.8 for testing.)

Jonah Simm

For the boat placement sound, it works in Survival but not in Creative. Weird...

Erik Broes

Using spawn-eggs spawns an "ambient sound" of the thing it spawned.

Jonah Simm

confirmed for 16w07a

Jonah Simm

confirmed for 1.9 pre-1

Jonah Simm

confirmed for 1.9 pre-2

bemoty

Can confirm for MC 1.12.1, signs & banners don't have a placing sound, yet they do play a sound when they are destroyed.

TheTamedWolf

I just updated my old world to the newest snapshot 18w06a and now many sounds are not present or inaudible. opening/closing chests no longer have a sound walking on various blocks gives no sound. Ladders barely make it's sound (if it does it is very quiet even when using a speaker.) Though I did update directly from 1.12.2 to 18w06a didn't think there would be this much 'damage' XD I will update if something changes or if I find something else.

migrated

Can confirm for 18w19b. Here are the ones I found that are missing sounds:

Planting seeds, vegetables, etc. (Destroying them makes a sound.) Types are:

netherwart
cocoa beans
pumpkin seeds
melon seeds
seeds
beet seeds
carrots
potatoes

Spawning eggs don't make noise when used. All mobs make noise upon spawning, except turtles, creepers, rabbits, salmon, cod, and tropical fish.

Placing a boat on land or water.

Using bonemeal on saplings, planted seeds, and mushrooms.

Placing additional seapickles or turtle eggs on the same block after the first seapickle or turtle egg is placed (above and below water).

Placing flowers in flowerpots (all types).

Bouncing on a slime block.

Placing an end crystal.

Using a redstone repeater.

Placing a minecart (all types) on a rail.

Opening a chest in a minecart.

Brewing stands don't make noise when they are operating, but they do make a noise the potion is finished.

Dyeing sheep.

Putting record in jukebox and removing record from jukebox.

migrated

@unknown: Sounds like another issue. I couldn't find a bug report similar to what you explained. Can you make your Minecraft make no sounds again and then send a debug crash by holding the F3 button and the C button for 10 seconds and then send the debug crash file in a new bug report? Then we may be able to see why this happens

migrated

@unknown: Thanks for mentioning more examples. I will add them. But I just want to say that most of the examples you wrote already was written in the bug report. You should read the bug description first before making searching for more examples in Minecraft. I say this to save your time if you want to find more examples in bug reports in the future 🙂

migrated

Confirmed for 18w22a, with the following exception:

Placing additional sea pickles or turtle eggs on the same block after the first sea pickle or turtle egg is placed (above and below water) now makes a sound.

lord.quadrato

Yes I can confirm for 18w22c, and like @Jeb Ivins said sea pickles and turtle eggs now make sounds when being placed and when walking on them

lord.quadrato

Confirmed for 1.13-pre3. Personally I think no sound for putting a disc into a jukebox is intended because the music starts right away. I think this would be annoying

migrated

Confirmed for 1.13.1.

muzikbike

Does walking on shulker produce a sound?

muzikbike

Apparently crops are fixed in 19w03a

migrated

bells,scaffholding,sounds from 19w03a also can't be heard

muzikbike

Relates to MC-135157

muzikbike

Cocoa bean placement appears fixed as of 19w14b

muzikbike

A couple more:

  • Redstone ore doesn't produce a sound when you right click on it, which causes a block state change. Relates to MC-161151

  • Entering a bed also doesn't make a sound, despite this changing the occupied block state to true.

  • Certain projectiles don't have sounds when they collide with something (i.e. eggs, snowballs, ender pearls)

muzikbike

Making animals sit or stand also doesn't play a sound.

Should this ticket be split up? It's a pretty long one. Also can the fixed cases be removed?

Relates to MC-94060

muzikbike

Relates to MC-165745.

I really think this ticket should be split up though. Would I be allowed to do this?

muzikbike

don't forget redstone cross switching

Adrian Östergård

This is a feature request.

migrated

Dude, but why is this a feature request, this is a bug

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Sound

sound, soundEvent, sound_missing

Minecraft 1.8.8, Minecraft 15w47c, Minecraft 15w49a, Minecraft 15w49b, Minecraft 15w50a, ..., 19w45b, 1.15.2, 20w07a, 1.16.2, 1.16.3

Retrieved