mojira.dev
MC-94007

Piston can push NoGravity ArmorStand

Pistons can still push NoGravity armor stands, even though NoGravity should disable all physics on the stand.

To test:

1. Summon NoGravity armor stand
2. Point a piston at it
3. Power piston to see it is moved

NoGravity ArmorStands are not affected by other physics interactions (excluding being a passenger of another entity) such as explosions and water, .

Related issues

Comments

onnowhere

According to MC-75197, Marker armor stands are still affected by physics and so should be able to be pushed. [Mod] Torabi also noted that the NoGravity tag should be used to prevent physics acting on the armor stand

[Mod] Torabi added a comment - 03/Sep/15 6:53 AM
Use the NoGravity tag if you don't want the armor stand to be affected by physics. That's what it's there for.

migrated

Pistons aren't gravity.

onnowhere

But neither is water and explosions. Water pushes it with force not gravity and explosions do as well. In zero gravity in real life, water or explosions shot at you would still move you, however the armor stand with NoGravity does not. I believe the intention of the NoGravity tag is to prevent physics from interacting on the stand rather than just gravity. Testing this with a shulker, the shulker does seem to move the nogravity armor stand at first, but no matter which direction, eventually the armor stand slingshots back into its original place suggesting that it shouldn't be being moved. Also, armor stands with NoGravity are not affected by Sweep Attacks either.

migrated

Also, armor stands with NoGravity are not affected by Sweep Attacks either.

Since you said that, they are affected by

/entitydata @e[type=ArmorStand] {Motion:[0.5]}

So they still can be moved.

migrated

Confirmed for 15w49b.

migrated

Reopened for Mojang to decide.

migrated

I can understand that "mere" NoGravity-AS should be able to be interfered with, as they are entities (albeit special ones), but MC-100398 should not happen:
Even if you set the Marker-tag to true, NoGravity-ArmorStands can be pushed from all directions.

onnowhere

Erik Broes

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 15w49b, Minecraft 15w50a, Minecraft 15w51b, Minecraft 16w03a, Minecraft 16w04a, ..., Minecraft 1.9.1 Pre-Release 2, Minecraft 1.9.1 Pre-Release 3, Minecraft 1.9.1, Minecraft 1.9.2, Minecraft 1.9.4

Retrieved