mojira.dev
MCPE-139036

Trees found growing on Gravel, Sand, and Clay blocks

Steps to Reproduce:

  1. Use the world seed -770728766

  2. /tp to the following coordinates:

    -91 63 57
    -83 63 67
    -1481 65 -2067
    -6050 63 -5463
    -4960 62 -4815

Observed Results:
The trees are growing on the wrong blocks such as sand, gravel, and clay.

Expected Results:
Trees should only generate on dirt or grass.


Original Description:
Upon loading a world in the new beta, I have found naturally generated Trees growing on Gravel, Sand, and Clay Blocks. 

 

Seed: 513337564 /with Cave & Cliffs experimental features switched on.

Upon first loading turn around 180 degrees, & walk 42 blocks. Then turn 90 degrees right, & walk 80 blocks. Trees are there.

 

The cords are 171, 63, -37.

 

However, the trees from this seed & cords are relocated or do not exist as a world generation bug fix changed the landscape.

I have still found trees naturally generated growing on both/either gravel & sand in the latest betas, though they are uncommon.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 14

Can you provide images/screenshots?

[Mod] OcelotOnesie

Please also provide the world seed and coordinates.

I have no idea how to provide screenshots from the PC version of bedrock. Unlike in Java, F2 seems disabled.

I have updated my bug report (above) with the world seed, and basic walking directions. I have no idea how to get cords on Bedrock. 

Must have Caves & Cliffs experimental features switched on.

[Mod] OcelotOnesie

You can take a screenshot by pressing the Prt Sc key. Coordinates can be displayed by enabling "Show Coordinates" in the world options.

The cords are 171, 63, -37.

I have no Prt Sc key, as my 15.6 laptop doesn't have a full keyboard. I can't provide a screenshot, sorry.

I hope a future update would change the key bindings, that aren't assessable to everyone's keyboard.

My keyboard ends at the enter button.

4 more comments
[Mod] OcelotOnesie

Could you please provide the seed and coordinates?

From the latest beta on Minecraft Bedrock; 1.18.10.20

Seed -770728766

Birth Tree  naturally generated on sand block.
-91/63/57 
Oak Tree  naturally generated on sand block.
-82/63/67 
Spruce Tree naturally generated on sand block.
-1479/64/2068

Spruce Tree  naturally generated on gravel block.
-6050/63/5463

Oak Tree  naturally generated on clay block. 
-1377/62/-3806
Spruce Tree  naturally generated on clay block.
-4959/62/-4815

1.19 Pre-Release 1

Seed 4513580350434781622

-2479, 63, 4438

Oak tree growing on clay block

[media]
[Mod] OcelotOnesie

Please see MC-228328 for the issue on Java Edition.

Also affects with Android device, Which caused from duplicated ticket (MCPE-179625)

Squarefist

(Unassigned)

665369

Confirmed

Multiple

19043.1165

1.18.10.20 Beta, 1.17.30.22 Beta, 1.19.2 Hotfix, 1.20.71 Hotfix, 1.20.81 Hotfix, 1.21.50

Retrieved