One Chorus Fruit Can Generate or One Piece. This may be caused from another bug as someone duplicated this on the same seed in an earlier version without Caves n Cliffs Enabled.
Steps To Reproduce:
Step 1: Create world with seed = -1188336055 (experimental setting does not matter)
Step 2: Go to End
Step 3: /tp @s 1375 52 67
Observed Result:
One Block of Chorus Fruit Can Generate
Expected Result:
One Block of Chorus Fruit alone Shouldn't be able to Generate.
Attachments
Comments 10
Okay odd as i can’t duplicate what you did either as i loaded a random seed with no experimental gameplay and didn’t get the same result in 1.17.11 maybe there’s another bug causing this bug
I updated the version to include 1.17.11 as we don't know if there's a earlier version than that so hopefully this is a valid bug report and gets fixed to match java
Is there any reason to think this is a bug? Just being different from Java does not make it a bug. I don’t see any negative impact on gameplay here, nor anything unintuitive about the behavior.
No, Imagine i have no food in the end but the only thing i find is one block of chorus fruit that puts Bedrock Players at a disadvantage compared to Java when beating the game as chorus fruit can generate in one block which, is next to nothing in food so, the player may lose in Bedrock from hunger but in Java they will get enough Chorus Fruit to survive to make it back to Overworld.
Z: I don't follow your logic. In Java the chorus fruit would not generate there at all, so the Java player would be more likely to die of hunger. But the scenario is far-fetched: chorus trees generate in large forests and the idea that you could be stranded on a island where the only chorus fruit is on the very edges is surely statistically impossible.
https://bugs.mojang.com/browse/MCPE-140149?focusedCommentId=1066338&page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels%3Acomment-tabpanel#comment-1066338
That is, you want to say that in version 1.17.11 in the same seeds on the same coordinates Chorus Fruit is not generated (on the edge)? Please attach the corresponding images (1.17.11 / 1.17.30) to the report.