Updated description by @unknown
Summary:
Banner patterns on shields and banners look different despite having identical designs.
Steps to reproduce:
Create a banner with a banner pattern.
Create a shield with the same banner pattern on it.
Compare the banner pattern on the shield with the banner pattern on the banner.
Observed results:
Banner patterns on shields and banners look different despite having identical designs.
Expected results:
Banner patterns on shields and banners would not look different when having identical designs.
Original Description:
When customizing the banner and placing it in the dark (customizing the shield) the banner image is not correctly placed on the shield (changing the image). including simple, complex figures and predefined patterns in the game.
Note: The same bug happens in minecraft java edition version (MC-86135).
Linked issues
is duplicated by 8
BDS-18431
Banners on shield aren't looking the same as before you put them on
Resolved
MCPE-169729
low resolution shields with banners
Resolved
MCPE-171333
Bug recipe custom shield
Resolved
MCPE-171468
The pattern on the shield does not match the pattern on the banner
Resolved
MCPE-173128
When dyed banners are placed on shields, the patterns get weird
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 6
Unfortunately, this error is difficult to fix because the resource went to Minecraft Bedrock with the same error and because the shield has fewer pixels than the banner.
With that in mind, a poster was created in the ideas area to get to Minecraft called “Power of combining banners with helmets”. Showing ideas, thoughts and situations that can help this feature reach the game. Anyone who wants to support can vote on the official Minecraft website where this poster was made:
It absolutely can easily be fixed regardless of those things; porting happens all the time, and all that needs to match is uv mapping; whether pixel size is different from the base shield texture means nothing.
Simply copy pasting the banner pattern textures and moving them to the appropriate area in the texture mapping so UV is the same fixes this.
I tried talking to a developer called @JasperBoerstra (Jappa) on Twitter and he commented on the amount of pixels between the shield and the banner. I know that it is possible to fix this bug, but unfortunately the execution seems difficult.
Twitter post link: https://twitter.com/Qwa08613302/status/1647333314548703235
The size of the shield compared to the banner is smaller, that means the game has to make the banner shield small/fit. This also happens to java edition