[MCPE-179887] Trial chambers can generate exposed to the air

Bedrock Edition repost of MC-266446 (resolved as Won't Fix).

Comment by slicedlime
Improved in 1.20.5-pre1. Remaining cases are from carvers (not noise caves), and are considered Won't fix status.

Trial chambers can generate exposed to the air, relates to MCPE-146753.

Seed: 3317253191420042803
Coordinates: -1084 -1 584

1.21.30.21 ~ 1.21.30.23

Seed: 3317253191420042803
Coordinates 1: -1107 -8 599
Coordinates 2: -251 -14 -1666

Steps to Reproduce:

Create a new world using the given seed.
Teleport to the given coordinates.

Observed Results:
Trial chambers can generate exposed to the air.

Expected Results:
Trial chambers shouldn't generate exposed to the air.

Linked issues

relates to 1

MC-266446 Trial chambers can generate exposed to the air Resolved

Attachments

Comments 5

migrated 2024-03-20T20:37:02Z

[media][media]

KR_ 2024-03-21T07:52:07Z

Can confirm.

JervieA20 2024-03-21T08:55:51Z

Also same affects with android.

I did confirm at same identical air exposure with a same seed.

(-6984109016527939300 9851 -13 -144)

Invisible826 2024-04-10T18:20:01Z

Despite the following quote has been mentioned in the 1.21.0.21 changelog, this is still an issue in 1.21.0.21 (for carver caves I think).

Trial Chambers are now more consistently buried by terrain when found underground

Added another instance where a trial chambers intersected a canyon.

Minecraft386882 2024-12-14T02:27:50Z

The blocks that the trial chambers cover themselves with should also generate additional blocks to try to blend with the caves to make the cave seem to 'end' and not just cut it off.