mojira.dev
MCPE-31503

Half-block dips are lit inconsistently depending on constituent blocks

searched

Central dip: 4 inner corner stairs

Edge dips: 2 regular stairs facing into each other

Corner dips: Slab blocks

The lighting seen across these different types of half-block descents is not consistent, when it obviously should be. Assuming the lighting applied to the slabs is the expected lighting effect.

To reproduce, recreate the structure and make sure Smooth Lighting is on.

Attachments

Comments 12

Before anyone asks: bug is still present without any texture packs.

Were all the dips in your screenshot made with 4 inside corner stair blocks?

They were made using different combinations of partial blocks which I had already detailed in the report.

Could not reproduce in 1.2.11.4 on Windows 10. It your screenshot it looks like it could be related to MCPE-30509, but that bug has been fixed on Windows 10 at least.

Affects 1.2.13. Surely the lighting discrepancies shouldn't be too difficult to see?

2 more comments

I do think this issue might be working as intended.

The amount of shadow (with smooth lighting) gets calculated from the number of full blocks surrounding the slab or stair.
In the example the amount of full blocks surrounding the slab or stair varies.

[media]


Where slabs are the darkest and surrounded by 4 full blocks.
And two stairs connecting for each stair are surrounded by 3 full blocks.
And the 4 stairs in a square for each stair are surrounded by 2 full blocks.
Causing the differences in shadow.

Image from testing (in 1.2.20.1):

[media]

In that case wouldn't Won't Fix be better?

Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been closed as Working as Intended.

If you need help or have a suggestion you might like to follow the community support link below.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Feedback – 📖 Game Wiki

As I said, this should be Won't Fix, not Works as Intended. I doubt they'd intentionally code this to happen.

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Tablet - iOS - iPad Air 2

1.2.11.4, 1.2.14.3, 1.2.13.54, 1.2.15.01, 1.2.16.3

Retrieved