mojira.dev
MCPE-31896

Player Hitbox incorrect when gliding, swimming, and using riptide

It is impossible to interact with the world normally while using an elytra (singularly shown here) or swimming (for projectiles only). While in any of these states, world interaction must happen one block below the interaction point, depending on the direction that the player is facing latitude.

Video Examples:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/haeoi5bmsx8f9lj/Player%20Hitbox%20Errors.mp4?dl=0
https://youtu.be/_m-YKJslZXA

The following things happen at the wrong position while gliding with an elytra or using riptide:

  • The position from where you are aiming at blocks and entities is too high

  • When you are below a ceilling, you will take suffocation damage

  • If you throw snowballs, eggs, splash potions, experience bottles or ender pearls it will be spawned above you

  • If you shoot an arrow, it will spawn above you

  • If you drop an item, it will spawn above you

  • If you eat, the eating paritcles appear too high

  • The position where loyalty tridents return to is too high

  • The position where phantoms fly to when attacking you is too high

  • If you die from crashing into a wall where it makes a corner with a ceiling, your items glitch upward through the ceiling.

The following things also happen while you are in swimming mode:

  • If you throw snowballs, eggs, splash potions, experience bottles or ender pearls, it will spawn above you

  • If you shoot an arrow, it will spawn above you.

  • If you drop an item, it will spawn above you.

  • The position where loyalty tridents return to is too high

  • The position where phantoms fly to when attacking you is too high

Related issues

MCPE-32366 Flying into Ceiling with Elytra causes suffocation damage MCPE-44921 Damaged while flying near nether roof MCPE-45570 Arrows fired offset while gliding with elytra MCPE-55871 Not aiming correctly while gliding MCPE-61130 Flying glitch MCPE-65986 A BUG !!! Shooting arrow under water. MCPE-73105 Player view point is misplaced from camera when using an elytra MCPE-74678 suffication when going through 1 by 1 tunnel with elytra MCPE-77349 Flying Under Ceiling Suffocates Player MCPE-90608 Flying In A Berry Bush With An Elytra, Causes You To Look In The Incorrect Location MCPE-97972 you take damage while flying with your head touching the roof (PARITY!) MCPE-99491 Sneaking/crawling doesn't change arrow position when shooting a bow MCPE-103709 Player suffocates with elytras MCPE-116988 Flying With Elytra, Can Prevent Loyalty Tridents From Returning To You MCPE-122076 placing blocks through wall when wearing elytra MCPE-127459 flying with elytra near the ceiling cause you damage MCPE-132444 Damage with elytra when flying under a roof MCPE-141053 Flying on a ceiling with elytra can cause clipping and suffocation damage in survival MCPE-147774 Elytra suffocation MCPE-153050 Player Hitbox MCPE-153478 when flying with the elytras and we put the player near a ceiling he begins to suffocate MCPE-154590 Suffocate when flying below blocks MCPE-155033 If using an elytra in the nether, you could loose all your things MCPE-158212 flying using elytra wings on or near block ceilings deals suffocation damage MCPE-161715 Elytra works incorrectly , in a fly mode your aim is 1 block above. MCPE-162683 Player eye height does not change dependent on movement state MCPE-162967 Items Dropped While Swimming on a One Block High and One Block Wide Tunnel Despawn and Disappear (Realm) MCPE-163222 suffocation damage when flying

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media]
migrated

The swimming works entirely different than the elytra[which suggests that you tested this in an earlier version]. The update aquatic has been implemented along with swimming animation which enables the player to swim in a 1x1 gap. But, what you showed may be a bug.

Makzevu

I fixed the bug report now. I just forgot to remove the rest of it.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Testing in the latest 1.12.0.4 beta, I was only able to reproduce the issue whilst flying with Elytra equipped. When swimming, the hits or block interactions happened exactly where the crosshair was - do you have any further steps to reproduce the bug while swimming?

Makzevu

In 1.6, some of the issues that are a problem with the elytra currently were fixed (on top of the fact that the swimming mode didn't experience every issue, regardless, that the elytra has today). However, using a trident, fishing rod, bow (crossbow), and any throw-able projectile (ender pearl, snowball, experience bottle, etc.) while in the swimming mode will occur one block above wherever the player used it.

migrated

I am playing on xbox one and also experienced this a very long time ago. 

While gliding you interect with blocks and entities like you are higher and things that you throw drop or shoot appear above you. 

While swimming with the swimming animation you interect with blocks and entities correctly but things that you throw drop or shoot appear above you. 

migrated

Still affects 1.14

migrated

confirmed for 1.14.1, 1.14.20 and 1.14.30

migrated

Eating particles also appear above the player when eating while gliding.

GoldenHelmet

I wonder if the fix to MCPE-35769 in the 1.16.0.51 beta affects the swimming side of this bug?

migrated

Confirmed for 1.14.60

migrated

Confirmed for 1.16.1. This also affects flying on the underside as the player takes damage.
Video: https://youtu.be/fyHQ2yRcH9Y

migrated

Let me just say that this bug means working in lava with elytra on the biggest pain ever. I can't us a bucket to pick up lava or place blocks inside of it because the elytra engage, I wind up "laying down", and everything happens one block above where my camera is. I have clipped into the ceiling countless times as a result as well.

migrated

affects 1.16.100.52

migrated

This also affects crawling as it prevents players from making a 1x1 block strip mine

Makzevu

Some of the reproduction methods of this issue are being blocked by MCPE-98271 in the betas, as it is impossible to enter 1x1 areas with an elytra or swimming outright.

For the most part, if you are in a non-beta version of the game, you don't have to worry about the other ticket. If you are in a beta, MCPE-98271 is affecting you.

migrated

Affects 1.16.100.55 Beta

osfanbuff63

Does this relate to MCPE-109925?

migrated

this affects version 1.19.2

Sprunkles

This bug also affects the new /execute anchored introduced in Preview 1.19.40.23. I am surprised nobody has made any mention of "eye height" in this entire report, it made finding it difficult in regard to /execute anchored as this is a pretty common concept in Java Edition. It has been mentioned now though.

migrated

Coming from Java Edition and now playing Bedrock with some friends, I find this issue REALLY annoying. It's almost impossible to fly long 2x3 tunnels in the nether without constantly taking damage. Please fix this issue.

Edit: Just tried 1.19.70.24 Preview, this is still an issue.

[Mod] OcelotOnesie

For the remaining issues in 1.19.70, please refer to MCPE-166473.

nicomoon04

I have detected that this bug appears again in release 1.21.51, Windows version

Makzevu

(Unassigned)

224330

Confirmed

Multiple

1909 (18363.535)

Elytra, Entity, Hitbox, Swim

1.19.70.24/25 Preview, 1.19.40.23 Preview, 1.13.0.1 Beta, 1.12.0.14 Beta, 1.19.0.25 Preview, ..., 1.18.31, 1.19.2 Hotfix, 1.19.21 Hotfix, 1.19.30, 1.19.31 Hotfix

1.19.70.20 Preview, 1.19.70

Retrieved