mojira.dev
MCPE-35072

Blaze and skeleton drop issue.

I build a skeleton xp farm and when I spend 25 minutes of grind xp and drops only 8 bones droped with 100 skeletons droped but arrows and bows is dropes normaly. In nether I killed 20 blazes and get only 1 blaze rod. I don't know other mobs drop items normaly but I only found this issue with skeletons and blazes. My device is Samsung galaxy J7 2017

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media]
migrated

...add to this zombies don't drop iron, drowned stopped dropping gold & tridents.

migrated

...add to this zombies don't drop iron, drowned stopped dropping gold & tridents.

migrated

I have this problem as well in the latest official version, I've tried all sorts of killing methods but the skeletons very rarely drops bones which is odd for this mob, killed like a hundred skeletons and only got one bone.

migrated

I have this problem as well in the latest official version, I've tried all sorts of killing methods but the skeletons very rarely drops bones which is odd for this mob, killed like a hundred skeletons and only got one bone.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

For those still experiencing this bug, please could you let us know the following:
• Device information
• Game version used
• Realm or singleplayer
• Any steps the preceded the drops not working correctly (eg when did you notice this happening?)
• If possible, please attach a copy of the world save

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

For those still experiencing this bug, please could you let us know the following:
• Device information
• Game version used
• Realm or singleplayer
• Any steps the preceded the drops not working correctly (eg when did you notice this happening?)
• If possible, please attach a copy of the world save

migrated

Same problem. 

Playing on a Galaxy 9s

Android version 8.0.0

Minecraft version: 1.6.0

Hard single player

After taking a long break from minecraft (about a year) I've noticed a sharp decrease in the number of all types of monsters compared to my previous experience. 

migrated

Same problem. 

Playing on a Galaxy 9s

Android version 8.0.0

Minecraft version: 1.6.0

Hard single player

After taking a long break from minecraft (about a year) I've noticed a sharp decrease in the number of all types of monsters compared to my previous experience. 

migrated

...and now guardians rarely drop crystals. If you want my game stats, look up my "duplicate bug post".

migrated

...and now guardians rarely drop crystals. If you want my game stats, look up my "duplicate bug post".

migrated

Bedrock 1.6.0.14
Galaxy tab s3 android 8.0.0
Skeletons droping a bone less than 1 in 20 skeletons killed.

migrated

Bedrock 1.6.0.14
Galaxy tab s3 android 8.0.0
Skeletons droping a bone less than 1 in 20 skeletons killed.

migrated

It happened at the last update.

migrated

It happened at the last update.

migrated

Ugh, without bones = no wheat auto = no cow auto = weak chicken farm = lame food = slower dig grind = my ultimate slime farm not finishing.

migrated

Ugh, without bones = no wheat auto = no cow auto = weak chicken farm = lame food = slower dig grind = my ultimate slime farm not finishing.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response

Is this still an issue in the latest version? (1.6.1)

This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Feedback – 📖 Game Wiki

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response

Is this still an issue in the latest version? (1.6.1)

This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Feedback – 📖 Game Wiki

migrated

It still happens in the latest version, skeletons still drop so little bones

migrated

It still happens in the latest version, skeletons still drop so little bones

Desert Prince

Agreed. This affects not only skeletons but also spiders. I have killed tons of spiders and only accumulated 4 spider eyes and that is using a Looting III sword. Same with skeletons and throughout game cycle only obtained a handful of bones. It is almost as if Looting does not affect the drops. Conversely, I have killed a bunch of rabbits with a regular stone sword with no enchantments and have obtained 25 rabbits feet, almost one per kill, something that is statistically impossible. Something is definitely wrong with the drops mechanic.

migrated

Playing on Samsung Galaxy S6, skeletons not dropping bones, blaze don't drop blaze rods, endermen not dropping ender pearls and phantoms not dropping phantom membrane. Looting 3 enchantment is not working on most mobs.
version 1.6.1

migrated

Playing on Samsung Galaxy S6, skeletons not dropping bones, blaze don't drop blaze rods, endermen not dropping ender pearls and phantoms not dropping phantom membrane. Looting 3 enchantment is not working on most mobs.
version 1.6.1

migrated

This is frustrating, being without bones for over a month. If it helps to solve issue at all: I built a general mob farm, in which mobs spawning naturally are killed by magma blocks, not the player. I do seem to be getting bone drops from that, so I suspect it's a killed by player issue.

migrated

This is frustrating, being without bones for over a month. If it helps to solve issue at all: I built a general mob farm, in which mobs spawning naturally are killed by magma blocks, not the player. I do seem to be getting bone drops from that, so I suspect it's a killed by player issue.

migrated

Actually, disregard last comment. I just did extensive testing on vs player kill and passive kill. Both appeared the same drop rate, both very low on pixel2, but about the same.

migrated

Actually, disregard last comment. I just did extensive testing on vs player kill and passive kill. Both appeared the same drop rate, both very low on pixel2, but about the same.

migrated

This is true, I have same problems on my OnePlus 6 MCPE. I've build skeleton xp farm, and actually I get pity amounts of bones, while a lot of unnecessary bows. Please fix it, because it ruins my whole gameplay.

migrated

This is true, I have same problems on my OnePlus 6 MCPE. I've build skeleton xp farm, and actually I get pity amounts of bones, while a lot of unnecessary bows. Please fix it, because it ruins my whole gameplay.

migrated

Skeleton bone drops seem to be fixed on my end. SSP 1.7 Update

Got more bones in 5 minutes of testing than 4 hours in 1.6.x

migrated

Skeleton bone drops seem to be fixed on my end. SSP 1.7 Update

Got more bones in 5 minutes of testing than 4 hours in 1.6.x

Auldrick

Although this bug wasn't mentioned in the change log, this bug appears to have been fixed as of 1.7.0. This report has therefore been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response.

Is this still an issue in the latest version (1.7.0) or later? If so, please comment with your device, the version you're using, and a brief explanation. This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.

Auldrick

Although this bug wasn't mentioned in the change log, this bug appears to have been fixed as of 1.7.0. This report has therefore been temporarily closed as Awaiting Response.

Is this still an issue in the latest version (1.7.0) or later? If so, please comment with your device, the version you're using, and a brief explanation. This ticket will automatically reopen when you reply.

migrated

Version 1.0.7.13 on a Pixel2. Right after update all of a sudden bones were dropping just fine. I've been playing for a while now and all of a sudden drops are messed up again. Endermen hardly drop pearls, zombie pigmen stopped flesh and gold bars, skeletons stopped bones. I've tried with and without looting3 sword. Neither works.

migrated

Version 1.0.7.13 on a Pixel2. Right after update all of a sudden bones were dropping just fine. I've been playing for a while now and all of a sudden drops are messed up again. Endermen hardly drop pearls, zombie pigmen stopped flesh and gold bars, skeletons stopped bones. I've tried with and without looting3 sword. Neither works.

migrated

Something to look into that may attribute: check if mob cap has effect. My entities are usually full due to an infinite villager spawner. Maybe this effects drop entity rates?

migrated

Something to look into that may attribute: check if mob cap has effect. My entities are usually full due to an infinite villager spawner. Maybe this effects drop entity rates?

migrated

My last comment tentatively confirmed on my end.

I finally got a thunderstorm, turned villagers to witches and killed them all, freeing up entity cap. I then went to skeleton farm and they were dropping bones again. I also checked pigmen farm, which is way outside of simulation distance, and they started dropping flesh again.

For anyone else with this problem: try freeing up entity cap (killing mobs, extra villagers, cows, cave lighting, etc.) Apparently simulation distance doesn't matter, there's some kind of world entity cap.

migrated

My last comment tentatively confirmed on my end.

I finally got a thunderstorm, turned villagers to witches and killed them all, freeing up entity cap. I then went to skeleton farm and they were dropping bones again. I also checked pigmen farm, which is way outside of simulation distance, and they started dropping flesh again.

For anyone else with this problem: try freeing up entity cap (killing mobs, extra villagers, cows, cave lighting, etc.) Apparently simulation distance doesn't matter, there's some kind of world entity cap.

migrated

I have the same problem, found a skeleton spawner and made a grinder out of it. It worked great for maybe 3 hours and then out of nowhere no drops at all. Tried using a looting 3 sword but no difference. Also tried reducing the amount of mobs around till the area was completely empty but no change. Can confirm that it's happening on two different devices at the moment. HTC u11 and OnePlus 5t both on 1.0.7.13. both survials mode on hard.

migrated

I have the same problem, found a skeleton spawner and made a grinder out of it. It worked great for maybe 3 hours and then out of nowhere no drops at all. Tried using a looting 3 sword but no difference. Also tried reducing the amount of mobs around till the area was completely empty but no change. Can confirm that it's happening on two different devices at the moment. HTC u11 and OnePlus 5t both on 1.0.7.13. both survials mode on hard.

Auldrick

@unknown: Thank you for searching first before creating a new ticket! However, I think your problem may not be the same as this one. You say your skeletons are dropping nothing at all, while in this ticket the skeletons were reported to be dropping normally, except for bones. In addition, this ticket was closed when its reporter and other commenters above confirmed that it was fixed in 1.7.0.

If you are actually getting some drops, but no bones, please comment below so we can reopen this ticket.
Otherwise, if you really are getting no drops at all as you stated, please search again for a closer match. If you can't find one, feel free to create a new report using the suggestions in the Issue Guidelines. If might also be helpful to attach a copy of your world, if possible.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki

Auldrick

@unknown: Thank you for searching first before creating a new ticket! However, I think your problem may not be the same as this one. You say your skeletons are dropping nothing at all, while in this ticket the skeletons were reported to be dropping normally, except for bones. In addition, this ticket was closed when its reporter and other commenters above confirmed that it was fixed in 1.7.0.

If you are actually getting some drops, but no bones, please comment below so we can reopen this ticket.
Otherwise, if you really are getting no drops at all as you stated, please search again for a closer match. If you can't find one, feel free to create a new report using the suggestions in the Issue Guidelines. If might also be helpful to attach a copy of your world, if possible.

Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Community Support – 📧 Customer Support – 📖 Game Wiki

migrated

(Unassigned)

142667

Confirmed

Phone - Android - Samsung Other (Specify in description)

7.0

1.6.0.5, 1.6.0

1.7.0

Retrieved