mojira.dev
MCPE-51087

Hoppers Don't Transfer Items In The Correct Order

Hoppers when transferring items, randomize the order at which the items get moved along. Aka, the hoppers are not reliably in which items they will send when.

This has been a massive issue for every kind of sorting system for as long as bedrock has existed, and it makes things needlessly complicated!

You can see a demonstration on this bug in action here!
https://youtu.be/1ei2sEELbxY?t=169

Linked issues

Comments 5

Chris

This doesn't get enough attention. We NEED reliable hoppers. This broke sorting systems as well as an auto potions lab when I converted my world to bedrock.

[Mojang] Mega_Spud (Jay)

This was covered by MCPE-28890, which is currently working as intended.

Mark Means

Since this is a parity issue between Java and Bedrock I think the issue should be reopened; or at least a reason provided why it is "working as intended" and why it is intended (i.e. what benefit exists for it) to be working differently than Java.

uniqueT

It absolutely is a bug. If not, you should formally declare that the hopper's order is random, like dropper or dispenser. The current situation is misleading.

Manuel Junior

This is definitely a bug!

silentwisperer

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Windows

windows 10

1.13.1, 1.12.1, 1.12.0

Retrieved