[MCPE-55278] Classic skins in skin packs are not saved when you reload the game

When you exit and reload the game, any characters in your profile that are based on classic skins from a Marketplace or custom skin pack are deleted. This doesn't happen for characters imported from a skin file.

Note: In my own testing on Windows 10, skins from Marketplace packs work correctly, but there are additional reports saying Marketplace skin packs have the same problem..

I have attached a sample skin pack that can be used to reproduce the issue.

Steps to reproduce:

Download the attached skin pack and double-click to install it in Minecraft.
On the main menu, select Profile.
Select any character, then click Edit Character.
Select the Classic Skins (2nd) tab.
Expand the Owned section. It should contain the Sample Skin Pack.
Choose any skin from the Sample Skin Pack.
Back out to the main menu. The selected skin should appear as your current skin.
Exit Minecraft and restart it.

Expected results:
Your current skin is the one you selected from the Sample Skin Pack.

Actual results:
Your current skin has been replaced with one of the defaults (Steve or Alex). If you open the Profile, the skin you selected is no longer saved in any character slot. The skin pack is still available on the Classic Skins tab, however.

Linked issues

is duplicated by

MCPE-56017 Custom Skins via Skin Packs don't save

MCPE-56553 Imported Skin packs not saving

Attachments

SampleSkinPack.mcpack

Comments

migrated 2019-11-04T21:38:02Z

Confirmed, this is the exact issue I am having on Xbox One and Android but with official Mojang skin packs from the Marketplace.

Auldrick 2019-11-04T21:43:00Z

I tested this quite a lot and couldn't get it to fail with a Marketplace skin pack in Windows 10. Could you please let us know the name of your pack, and verify that you're using 1.13.0?

migrated 2019-12-09T20:51:17Z

Yes, I can again verify that I've been on 1.13.0. It's the Minecraft Skin Pack 1, and the skin says Limited Usage which is incorrect.

Edit: I should clarify that this has been an issue specifically on Android and Xbox One since the 1.13 update. Version 1.14 for Android seems to fix the problem with skins resetting.

GoldenHelmet 2020-01-28T19:27:20Z

Is this related to MCPE-53398? It seems like the same behavior. Especially if the underlying issue is the game trying to verify something online (through the Microsoft account?) and not being able to for locally saved packs.