Updated description by @unknown
Steps to reproduce
Place an ice block on top of scaffolding, or place an ice block with air under it.
In survival mode, break the ice block.
Expected result
The ice block turns into a water source.
Actual result
The ice block is replaced by air.
Original description
Ice dose not turn in to water when Broken on air or scaffolding
Linked issues
is duplicated by 1
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 7
Buttons and conduits work differently between games. For Java Minecraft, breaking ice over a button doesn't create water, but breaking ice over a conduit does. However in Bedrock Minecraft, breaking ice over a button does create water, but breaking ice over conduit (even a waterlogged one) does not.
This is desynced even more when waterlogging levers, tripwire hooks, tripwires, and end rods in Bedrock Minecraft. The waterlogged variants of these blocks are only obtainable in Bedrock Minecraft; however breaking ice over these blocks does not create water either.
Regardless, in both Bedrock and Java, water can simply melt above transparent blocks (or air) and still create water.
Affects 1.17.10. Here I've compiled a list of blocks affected & unaffected; above blocks do not convert ice to water, below blocks do,
[media]
Ice only turns into water when there is a full block underneath it (whereas air and scaffolding aren't full blocks).