In the 1.11 video, I have view bobbing turned off and the items sway. In the 1.16 video, you can see me turning view bobbing off and the items don't sway. The hand also started having this issue in earlier updates.
Steps to Reproduce:
Turn view bobbing off
Move the camera in any direction with an empty hand or with an item
Observed Results:
The hand/item does not sway.
Expected Results:
The hand/item should sway.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 8
MCPE-111432
Hand Doesn't move when you turn off view bobbing
Resolved
MCPE-126835
When View Bobbing is turned off, it stays still unlike java which stays still but moves hand when you look around (parity).
Resolved
MCPE-131718
View bobbing off does not slightly sway your hand
Resolved
MCPE-137377
View bobbing in bedrock edition
Resolved
MCPE-142394
The items doesn't sway anymore after 1.13
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 10
Really? In the Java Edition, when view bobbing is turned off, it sways. Personally it looks weird stuck in one place and before, it swayed
Relates to MCPE-79380❓ , where your hand bobs despite if view bobbing is disabled.
Oh. Now I understand the issue. I though it was the hand swaying when walking, sorry. Yeah, not intended that’s for sure.
If I remember correctly, before this bug was a thing, only the item in your mainhand did that. Items in your offhand didn’t and when you mainhand was empty it didn’t do that either.
Thank you for your report!
However, this issue has been closed as Working as Intended.
If you need help or have a suggestion you might like to follow a link below.
Quick Links:
📓 Issue Guidelines – 💬 Mojang Support – 📧 Suggestions – 📖 Minecraft Wiki
it shouldnt be closed for working as intended since its not the same as java edition. The slight sway of the hands gives it realism without having it to bob every time. Right now it looks like an image pasted in first person
@New Engine Bad I agree! Why hasnt anyone made a fix for this as View Bobbing is OFF? The only thing I can find which is this Java Hand and View Bobbing pack, but even then it still requires the option to be on and/or is bugged out.
For instance, when you hold an item, it still bobs normally, but whats even worse is that when "swimming" in a crawlspace or even in certain resource packs that change the animations, it bobs UP instead of DOWN
This is intentional. View bobbing when off means your hands will not bob around nor your camera.