mojira.dev

mostly_wright

Assigned

No issues.

Reported

MCL-22062 Cannot run older releases on java minecraft launcher Duplicate MC-254650 All villagers with saved memory disappear when upgrading to 1.19.1 Awaiting Response

Comments

(MC-252565)  does not address the villager issue. It does address the issue of running older worlds that I also raised in MCL-22062 which I have resolved. Villagers still disappear when loading my 14.2 world in new worlds later than 15.1 

The behavior is identical to  MC-172078 which was resolved by a patch to 15.2. But seems to have returned. Perhaps there is a clue there to the fix.

should be 14.2 . WorldVersion 1963

 

My bad. I saved it in a 17.1 world when testing. I've put the original world up.

Here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1PKbLUWFqAuto4IqS3et2ZdRSoOQiNzSR/view?usp=sharing

 

Update: by disabling the AMD option in the minecraft launcher I was able to run older worlds. This 14.2 world loads in 15.1 with villagers retained but at 16.4 and later they disappear (I did not try any releases or patches between 15.1 and 16.4).

yes it is set. later versions such as 19.1 and 17.1 will load and run. but 14.1 seems to not have the libraries under java8 or even java8 available for download. Disabling and creating a new 15.1 world actually works, and loads 14.1 world with villagers still alive. So this seems to be the solution. Thanks! Didn't occur to me to look for game settings outside of the world java options.

 

why is this marked resolved?

world exceeds 10MB upload limit. Instead I'm providing a link to it on a google drive. Hope thats ok. Its 300MB. I can't reproduce with a minimum example because java edition cannot run 1.14.1 on a mac m1 amd processor. 

 

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1H2wPtTDv-4izBtv29svDCBwD6X9D7d_Q/view?usp=sharing

These are not deaths. no deaths logged. Rather the villagers are gone immediately upon loading a 1.14.1 world in 1.19. EG a village with about 50 villagers and only iron golems left. Including villagers confined to a few squares in a well lit house with a bed. But a villager used in a villager farm who has never been interacted with is still there. As well as a single baby villager. This is the same behavior as in MC 172078