Some ids are unintuitive

@@unknown, there is a separate report for cases like this: MC-123529.

Sorry, removed #minecraft:waterlogged again, thought it was a compound word, but it is actually not

I don't agree with "clayball", it doesn't really exist as a single word and it's fine as it is now. Snowball is often used as a single word and slimeball is a fantasy item I guess, so those are fine as single words.

In that case (I'm not a native speaker, I was unaware of that), for the sake of consistency, I removed both clay_ball and slime_ball, and instead added snowball to change to snow_ball.

Also added lapis_block/ore as you requested on the other ticket.

I'm not a native speaker either 😃

"Snowball" seems to be by far the most common form. Language is often inconsistent and there's not much we can do about that. I would change the current kelp (which has no translation in en_us - related: MC-126022) to kelp_column and kelp_top (translated as "Kelp", used by both the top block and the inventory form) to just kelp. Also you forgot to remove lapis block and ore from the other ticket!

I already noted to change the kelp item to just kelp instead; the ids for the blocks already make sense.
Actually, I didn’t add the lapis block/ore to that ticket, some other mod/helper did. 🙂
EDIT: oh I did... don’t remember doing it though, ah well.

I don't think they can just change the item ID of kelps. Items that place blocks (sugar cane, sign, flower pot, etc.) now use the block translation so I'm believing that those items are just the blocks with a different icon for inventories. If this is indeed correct, they can't change only the kelp item as it's not different than the kelp_top.block.

So kelp (untranslated) -> kelp_column ("Kelp Column")
and kelp_top ("Kelp", both block and inventory form) -> kelp ("Kelp")
IMHO would be the best solution

Not all items placing blocks use the block id, seeds for example.

Oh right, that's true

Still affects 18w09a. I don't see any new ones, other than the structure id for the underwater ruins, Ocean_Ruins.

I'm not including generated structures in this list because they aren't resource locations (MC-107408) when that gets changed/fixed, they're likely getting named more appropriately then already.

Added advancements, recipes, structure files and sound events; and as a result the list became too big, do it's not a txt file in the attachments.

The formatting is messed up in the browser because you used too many tabs. I don't know what the tab size is set to in your text editor, but for me it looks messed up with tab size 10 and 3 for example. I think you should adjust it for tab size 8, which at least my browser uses (Chrome on Windows).

Moved to google document instead; prevents the breakage in formatting, and allows for editing it without sending a mail to everyone every time.

I found another inconsistency (which hasn't been added to the list yet (unless I'm blind)): the fireworks entity is called fireworks_rocket while the item is called firework_rocket

Relates to MC-123529 Some entity ids are not the same as the item id

You could add that inconsistencies between names and IDs for those items :

• leather_helmet, leather_chestplate and leather_leggings are named "Leather Cap", "Leather Tunic" and "Leather Pants" so it would be better that their IDs was leather_cap, leather_tunic and leather_pants

• clay_ball should be named "Clay Ball" and not "Clay"

• slime_ball should be named "Slime Ball" and not "Slimeball"

Is there a matching version of this for Bedrock? It would be most helpful if the fix for these inconsistencies were consistently applied to the other platform. In terms of using commands, I'd rather not have to think about what platform I'm using and have it "just work". In terms of command block structures and map makers for both platforms, I'm quite certain THEY don't want to have to remember inconsistent block-names/ item-names between platforms either.

1. Leather armor ids are consistent with other armor, so they are fine.

2. Display names is another ticket.

3. No matching bedrock version; but bedrock is also quite behind java looking at ids and block states in general.

Affects 1.13 pre-releases [1.13-pre1, 1.13-pre2, 1.13-pre3]!

Maybe the "Primed TNT" entity should be added, because its ID is tnt which doesn't follow the display name.

MC-124190 has that entity in its list but maybe that is the ID which should be changed and not the Display Name.

Still affects 1.13-pre6.

Lots of cases are still present in 1.13-pre7.

confirmed in 1.13-pre8

Confirmed in 1.13 and18w32a!

Confirmed in 1.13.1

Confirmed in 1.13.2

Confirmed on 18w45a

Confirmed on 19w05a

The particle campfire_cosy_smoke should use US spelling, "cozy".

"Smooth Quartz" should be "Smooth Quartz Block". It's inconsistent with "Chiseled Quartz Block", besides that it's derived from quartz blocks (just "quartz" is the item name).