mojira.dev
MC-126868

Dead coral variants have incorrect names, <Color> Dead Coral should be Dead <Color> Coral

It's simply proper (but slightly misunderstood!) English.

There's a little known rule to how adjectives are ordered in English:

  1. Quantity or number.

  2. Quality or opinion.

  3. Size.

  4. Age.

  5. Shape.

  6. Color.

  7. Proper adjective (often nationality, other place of origin, or material)

  8. Purpose or qualifier.

Dead is "Quality or Opinion".

Yellow is "Color".

Going by these rules, quality comes before color, so it should be "Dead Yellow Coral", while currently it is "Yellow Dead Coral".

Therefore, it should be "Dead <Color> Coral", instead of "<Color> Dead Coral." It just kinda sounds wrong in English.

Linked issues

Comments 6

It would make more sense as well, because the dead coral isn't yellow, but it's a yellow coral that's dead.

Also affects the ids.

not fixed for the ids.

Not fixed, the ids are still the same as 18w10b.

Resolving as fixed, adding the ids to MC-123540.

CreeperMagnet_

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

Minecraft 18w10b, Minecraft 18w10c

Minecraft 18w10c

Retrieved