The bug
I created a new world for 19w05a, executed the command /gamerule doMobSpawning false. And while trying out the new features in the snapshot; one Wandering Trader and Two Trader Llamas spawned.
Related issues
is duplicated by
MC-143531
Wandering Trader doesn't seem to obey the "doMobSpawning" gamerule
MC-143539
Wandering Trader spawn even when Domobspawning Is set to false
MC-143547
Wandering Trader Llamas
MC-143698
Wandering Trader spawning
MC-143828
Wandering Traders spawn even if the gamerule doMobSpawning is set to false
MC-143960
Merchant still appears naturally even with "the doMobSpawning" gamerule on false
MC-144103
Wandering Trader spawns when doMobSpawning is false
MC-144279
Wandering Trader Still Spawning
MC-144335
Wandering Traders/Llamas ignore gamerule DoMobSpawning false
MC-144908
Wandering Trader ignores doMobSpawning being false
MC-145186
Wandering trader still spawn when doMobSpawning is false
MC-145486
Wandering Trader still appears when doMobSpawning is off
MC-145489
Wandering trader spawns when mob spawning is set off
Attachments
Comments
migrated
migrated
all mobs that are generated with the chunk generation are affected by this; travel through plains and you might find horses.
The gamerule only affects post-generation natural spawning.
migrated
They did spawn naturally. The chunks were loaded for a while before they spawned. I was building and they appeared.
migrated
What does /gamemode doMobSpawning return?
migrated
False. What part of the sentence "I created a new world for 19w05a, executed the command /gamerule doMobSpawning false.", do you not understand?
migrated
It could've been you tab-completed it, and set doMobLoot instead. No need to start reacting in such a way.
migrated
No, it couldn't of. I checked I had executed the command correctly after they spawned initially (Using the up arrow).
migrated
Can confirm in 19w05a
migrated
I believe you. I had been building a scale model of my home town in a superflat with doMobSpawning off and then, three in-game days later, he and his llamas just appear while I was building with structure blocks. However, it was night at the time, so he was invisible.
(19w06a)
SolidBlock
confirmed in 19w06a
migrated
I have left my account running for a few hours in the new snapshot (19w08a) and there was no sign of any trader llamas or wandering traders during that time. I can no longer seem to recreate this bug, so it may be resolved.
Makzevu
Confirmed for 19w08b.
Hugman_76
Can approve this happens since these entities exist.
migrated
This happened to me too.
migrated
This definitely happens to me. They spawned even though "doMobSpawning" was set to "false" from the very beginning of my world. This is definitely a bug worth fixing.
KirbAvion
Confirmed in 19w09a.
migrated
I think the fix should be reverted since the addition of "doTraderSpawning".
boq