I keep throwing bread to different villagers. I built a large house with 4 beds in it (2 bunk beds now, they were separated before). There are 5 villagers, 2 of them working too far from gathering point, each one with their home and 2 extra beds aside of the 4 new beds I installed in the house I built.
They show hearts when at gathering point, many, many hearts, but then they always end up getting angry and not breeding. There's nothing obstructing the beds (a villager walked in and slept in one of the beds). I keep throwing them bread, they keep trying to mate, but always end up getting angry and just walking off.
Linked issues
Attachments
Comments 23
ive had this glitch as well, literally everything is the exact same as you described
ive had this glitch as well, literally everything is the exact same as you described
May you clarify?
I built a large house with 4 beds in it
There are 5 villagers
But I assume you mean you build an extra house and you do have enough beds. Make sure the villagers are not to far apart from each other, one way to test that would be to ring a bell and see if ALL of them move, otherwise your villagers might have created multiple villages.
May you clarify?
I built a large house with 4 beds in it
There are 5 villagers
But I assume you mean you build an extra house and you do have enough beds. Make sure the villagers are not to far apart from each other, one way to test that would be to ring a bell and see if ALL of them move, otherwise your villagers might have created multiple villages.
The village had 5 villagers initially with only 4 beds. I added a bed in one of the houses, so there'd be enough beds. Then, I had 5 villagers and 5 beds. I wanted more villagers, so I built a wall surrounding the village with some extra space to build more stuff inside, to be able to mine and build at night without worrying about mobs killing the villagers or the golem. I built a large house with 2 bunk beds, 4 beds in total. I also added a bed in a building with a work block. So now the village should have space for 10 villagers. Yet, I have 4 villagers (one of the five original villagers mysteriously disappeared, assuming he died, but many days ingame have passed since he went missing), I try to make them mate throwing bread at them, trading with them, they try to mate, lots of hearts appear, but then they get angry and fail. This has happened everytime I tried to make them breed, over 15 times already.
The village had 5 villagers initially with only 4 beds. I added a bed in one of the houses, so there'd be enough beds. Then, I had 5 villagers and 5 beds. I wanted more villagers, so I built a wall surrounding the village with some extra space to build more stuff inside, to be able to mine and build at night without worrying about mobs killing the villagers or the golem. I built a large house with 2 bunk beds, 4 beds in total. I also added a bed in a building with a work block. So now the village should have space for 10 villagers. Yet, I have 4 villagers (one of the five original villagers mysteriously disappeared, assuming he died, but many days ingame have passed since he went missing), I try to make them mate throwing bread at them, trading with them, they try to mate, lots of hearts appear, but then they get angry and fail. This has happened everytime I tried to make them breed, over 15 times already.
Same issue here since 1.14.4 (Survival mode, java edition with a local server).
It was working fine in 1.14.3 : I created a new village from 2 zombie villagers (with a mob farm), I locked the 2 healed villagers in a building, and added beds and given carrots to have 8 villagers splitted in 4 locked buildings.
I upgraded to 1.14.4, but now breeding is not working. I added 2 beds per building (so now there are 16 beds, 4 in each building), with 2 (unemployed) villagers per building. When I give them carrots, they start mating with lot of hearts, but at the end there is no baby villager and still only 2 villagers per building. They don't seem to get angry at the end, there is just no baby.
I don't know if it is related, but there is also another strange behavior since last upgrade: by night, villagers are going to bed, but from time to time they waking up (not all in the same time, but they are all impacted). They walk a bit then go back to bed (not always in the same bed, as there is more beds than villagers).
Same issue here since 1.14.4 (Survival mode, java edition with a local server).
It was working fine in 1.14.3 : I created a new village from 2 zombie villagers (with a mob farm), I locked the 2 healed villagers in a building, and added beds and given carrots to have 8 villagers splitted in 4 locked buildings.
I upgraded to 1.14.4, but now breeding is not working. I added 2 beds per building (so now there are 16 beds, 4 in each building), with 2 (unemployed) villagers per building. When I give them carrots, they start mating with lot of hearts, but at the end there is no baby villager and still only 2 villagers per building. They don't seem to get angry at the end, there is just no baby.
I don't know if it is related, but there is also another strange behavior since last upgrade: by night, villagers are going to bed, but from time to time they waking up (not all in the same time, but they are all impacted). They walk a bit then go back to bed (not always in the same bed, as there is more beds than villagers).
@Lofwyr That bottom thing is also happening to me. MC-157367
@Lofwyr That bottom thing is also happening to me. MC-157367
@Lofwyr that sounds like a different bug, which is Baby not spawning, while what happens here is Breeding failing for some reason even though every condition is correctly fulfilled.
@Lofwyr that sounds like a different bug, which is Baby not spawning, while what happens here is Breeding failing for some reason even though every condition is correctly fulfilled.
@Luis I retried today. Added a newly created bed in each room. Giving food to villagers by night when they are in bed so I'm sure each villager receive 12 carrots. At the morning they start mating with lot of hearts, and in fact they get angry at the end and fail. So it's the same bug.
I'm sure all beds are valid because of bug MC-157367 : by night, from time to time, they wake up and start searching again a bed, and they can use any of the available beds.
@Luis I retried today. Added a newly created bed in each room. Giving food to villagers by night when they are in bed so I'm sure each villager receive 12 carrots. At the morning they start mating with lot of hearts, and in fact they get angry at the end and fail. So it's the same bug.
I'm sure all beds are valid because of bug MC-157367 : by night, from time to time, they wake up and start searching again a bed, and they can use any of the available beds.
@Lofwyr Ah, then it is the same bug indeed. Btw I've tried 30 times now, Jesus. I should stop wasting so much bread.
Oh, I've found out about a specific villager staying outdoors at night, even though there are 2 villagers sleeping on the house I built with 4 beds, so he's not going to bed because of some other bug, cuz he's got plenty of accessible beds on his disposition. I just built a house near his workplace just in case, will update it next time I reply.
@Lofwyr Ah, then it is the same bug indeed. Btw I've tried 30 times now, Jesus. I should stop wasting so much bread.
Oh, I've found out about a specific villager staying outdoors at night, even though there are 2 villagers sleeping on the house I built with 4 beds, so he's not going to bed because of some other bug, cuz he's got plenty of accessible beds on his disposition. I just built a house near his workplace just in case, will update it next time I reply.
@Luis: I may have found a workaround... I was going to an old village to check if I have the same behavior, and it was exactly the same, except in one small room with 2 villagers and 2 beds. I added 1 bed, dropped 12 carrots to each villager, they started to mate and... bim, a new baby villager ! The only difference was the heigh of the room: it was the only room with 3 vertical blocks of free space (all other rooms only have 2 blocks height).
So I go back to my new village, push up the roof 1 block, give foods... and bim, a new baby ! Can you check on your side if you have same behavior ?
@Luis: I may have found a workaround... I was going to an old village to check if I have the same behavior, and it was exactly the same, except in one small room with 2 villagers and 2 beds. I added 1 bed, dropped 12 carrots to each villager, they started to mate and... bim, a new baby villager ! The only difference was the heigh of the room: it was the only room with 3 vertical blocks of free space (all other rooms only have 2 blocks height).
So I go back to my new village, push up the roof 1 block, give foods... and bim, a new baby ! Can you check on your side if you have same behavior ?
@Lofwyr Sadly, that isn't causing my problem. I always build leaving 3 blocks of height for insides, because when I build something with 2 blocks of height, I feel confined. Sucks being claustrophobic. I honestly don't know what makes them fail when mating. They have perfect roads, nobody dies inside due to the high lighting and security there is (A wall surrounding the village and impeding every mob to get in and three Iron Golems) and the high quantity of beds. There are 7 villagers now, I cured 3 zombie villagers (When you cure a zombie villager, that villager will give you a massive discount! That saved me soo many time of mining chunks of stone to find 3 diamonds, as I got a full-diamond enchanted armor for barely 2 emeralds each piece, and its original cost was over 20-32 per piece) and guess what! They found and claimed the beds from the building I built, so that means there were accessible beds. All requirements are fulfilled, so I no longer know why they won't stop failing when breeding.
P.D: And the staff seems like won't be replying until next month or so.
@Lofwyr Sadly, that isn't causing my problem. I always build leaving 3 blocks of height for insides, because when I build something with 2 blocks of height, I feel confined. Sucks being claustrophobic. I honestly don't know what makes them fail when mating. They have perfect roads, nobody dies inside due to the high lighting and security there is (A wall surrounding the village and impeding every mob to get in and three Iron Golems) and the high quantity of beds. There are 7 villagers now, I cured 3 zombie villagers (When you cure a zombie villager, that villager will give you a massive discount! That saved me soo many time of mining chunks of stone to find 3 diamonds, as I got a full-diamond enchanted armor for barely 2 emeralds each piece, and its original cost was over 20-32 per piece) and guess what! They found and claimed the beds from the building I built, so that means there were accessible beds. All requirements are fulfilled, so I no longer know why they won't stop failing when breeding.
P.D: And the staff seems like won't be replying until next month or so.
I did some testes and I can confirm that if beds are stacked on top of each-other (bunk bed configuration) the villagers do not detect the free beds to have a successful breed. Despite the fact that they can sleep in all of the beds.
I tried with 2 villager and 4 beds in bunk(2x2), one time stacked directly on top of each-other, and once with 1 free block between the beds.
The control with beds not stacked worked fine.
[Minecraft Java Edition 1.15.2]
[media][media][media][media]
I did some testes and I can confirm that if beds are stacked on top of each-other (bunk bed configuration) the villagers do not detect the free beds to have a successful breed. Despite the fact that they can sleep in all of the beds.
I tried with 2 villager and 4 beds in bunk(2x2), one time stacked directly on top of each-other, and once with 1 free block between the beds.
The control with beds not stacked worked fine.
[Minecraft Java Edition 1.15.2]
[media][media][media][media]