The bug concerning inconsistent hoe textures (MC-170556) was not fully fixed in 20w09a.
Stone, iron, and wooden hoes still use the incorrect stick pallet (the darkest color of the stick is incorrect on all of them). Golden hoes also still have one pixel miscolored on their sticks.
Additionally, the new 20w10a netherite hoe texture uses the incorrect stick pallet (the darkest color of the stick is incorrect) when compared with the other 20w10a netherite tools.
Linked issues
is duplicated by 5
MC-170316
Error with Iron Hoe Texture (1.14-1.15)
Resolved
MC-226784
The textures for the iron and stone hoes are colored incorrectly
Resolved
MC-263201
The texture of the iron hoe has a color bug
Resolved
MC-267671
The Colors On The Handles of Hoes Don't Match
Resolved
MC-300377
All hoes have a way darker shadow on the right sides of the item than other tools
Resolved
relates to 1
Attachments
Comments 10
This is a bug and doesn't work as intended. The wooden handles of items are consistent everywhere else except for here and the weird coloring is, stealing Potholed's words, obviously not intended and is a mistake. When you compare the dark side of the handle's color to other stick handles, the color doesn't even match up correctly. Please mark this as open as it is still a problem in the latest version.
The art director at Mojang has resolved this as intended. If you'd like this flagged for review, at least provide decent arguments why this should be reviewed/reconsidered, and not just "this is a mistake".
REALLY??? This Can't Be Right!!! This Doesn't Work As Intended! The Comments Here Give VERY good Proof That It Can't Be!
This is obviously a bug and should be flagged for review. There is no logical reason why these items would use inconsistent palettes; it is evidently just a texturing error, and to mark it as "Works as Intended" (not even "Won't Fix") feels like a blatant abuse of that resolution type.
This issue should be flagged for review, as I've provided an image that showcases the mistakes in texturing between the different hoe types. The gold hoe has a miscolored pixel at the top-right corner of the stick, and then stone/iron/wood/netherite hoes all use the incorrect color as the darkest color of their sticks. Diamond hoes do not have any of these issues, which is why this is a bug and not WAI.
Diamond hoes do not have any of these issues, which is why this is a bug and not WAI.
Huh?! Why can’t they have different textures? Why in the world are you guys so upset about this? Clearly this isn’t a bug, it’s just things having different textures, which is also realistic, and pretty cool they’re doing this. In fact, maybe the darker texture is supposed to be soil on the handle?
Did Jasper Boestra mark this (MC-174561) and MC-174564 as WAI? Both of these are obviously not intended and are bugs. I don't want to jump to conclusions, but as it is now this seems like a lazy resolution.