mojira.dev
MC-203572

Candles can float / don't need a support block

When breaking a block under the candles they are not destroyed, but float.

You can also place the candles on top of each other and also next to each other with no block underneath them.

Related issues

MC-203690 You can place candles on walls and they just float MC-203719 Candles can be placed on the ceiling and on walls MC-203756 Candles don't need block to be under them MC-203784 Rabbits get stuck when running into the side of a candle MC-203828 Candles not affected by gravity MC-203889 Candle cake tower MC-203986 Minecart and candle MC-203990 bed with candles MC-204004 Candle floating MC-204055 Candles can be placed on a dirt path, so they "levitate" in the air MC-204098 floating candles MC-204099 Multiple candle glitches (including dupe glitch MC-204140 When you place a candle down on a block and you break around the candle floats MC-204210 Candles without supporting block MC-204233 Floating candle bug MC-204235 Floating candles MC-204249 When right clicking a fifth time in a a candle 4x4 a new candle appears on mid air MC-204296 placing candles in midair in the new snapshot MC-204332 Candle placement MC-204551 Floating candles MC-206574 Candles don’t get broken when breaking the block underneath MC-206635 candles on not full blocks MC-207630 If you break a block under the candle, the candle not get breaked MC-207853 Floating candles are still here MC-211007 Candles can float MC-227431 The candle should float? MC-228333 Candles float when the block its standing on is destroyed MC-228431 candles float without any block under them MC-228969 蜡烛可悬浮在空中 Candles can be suspended in the air MC-234738 Candles can float with no block under them while torches and sea pickles can't MC-242460 Candles won't break if floating or on top of another candle MC-251908 flying candles MC-274508 Candle item floating without block support with lighting failing to render.

Attachments

Comments

migrated
[media][media][media]
migrated

Hey, I can confirm. 

Skelten454

This is unlike sea pickles where they can't be placed in the air.

[media]
migrated

While I can understand that this seems like a bug and is inconsistent with similar blocks, it's such a useful "feature", it'd be a shame to see it fixed.

migrated

Probably a feature request, since MC-178791 was a feature request.

migrated

So... what's the bug? A lot of blocks in Minecraft don't need supporting blocks. (for example flower pots, end rods, daylight sensors, etc.) Why should candles be any different? 

migrated

If it will be fixed, many decorations will be more difficult to build

migrated

I'm pretty sure many people will be disappointed if this gets "fixed". Preferably just keep it as an unintentional feature.

RobinDinVienna

When I saw this "bug" I instantly thought that you can finally build a magical castle with floating candles. Would be cool, but obviously it is an inconsistency with other such blocks... Maybe make them placable on string then at least. That would give the builders a workaround, but be consistent otherwise.

migrated

Works as Intended

migrated

if this gets changed then *sad grain noises*

violine1101
migrated

I'm sorry, I also created this "loophole". But I feel that candles and torches are similar, and they are the same size for lighting.

我很抱歉,我也创建了这个“漏洞”。但我感觉,蜡烛和火把差不多,都是用来照亮的一种大小一样的。

migrated

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

Block states

20w45a

Retrieved