mojira.dev
MC-223831

Farmland and dirt paths are not part of the #dirt block tag

MC-214129 was marked as fixed for this snapshot, but despite mentioning farmland, it remains outwith this tag.

Farmland's absence from this tag especially is without a doubt causative of many issues:

  • MC-168262: Dead bushes cannot be placed on top of it

  • MC-168264: Sugar cane cannot be placed on top of it

  • MC-168265: Bamboo cannot be placed on top of it

  • MC-195308: Twisting vines cannot be placed on top of it

While the blocks may have been left out of this tag due to not being full cubes, I do not consider this a valid excuse as a large number of other blocks (saplings, flowers, ...) can be placed on top of it already (being affected by MC-104092 and MC-164918 as a result, and even crops themselves are subject to MC-135269). If the absence from the tag is to be considered intended, non-crop blocks should probably be forbidden from being placed on it, however having them still be placeable on top would be preferable.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 7

Can confirm in 21w17a.

Note that fixing this would allow endermen to pick them up which allows players to obtain them as items in survival.

Maybe endermen holding these should drop dirt then.

...or they should become obtainable in survival.

Farmland and Dirt Path were, I believe, never intended to be obtainable outside of creative inventory.

Well maybe it's time we change that. No point in keeping perfectly valid survival-compatible items locked away behind creative or obscure glitches.

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Confirmed

(Unassigned)

block-missing-from-block-tag

21w16a, 21w17a, 21w18a

Retrieved