mojira.dev
MC-235698

Terracotta still uses the pre-1.12 color scheme

Closely relates to MC-161716, which likely has a similar root cause (colored stuff being excluded in early Texture Update revisions) and can be fixed alongside it. Possibly also related, if more tenuously, to MC-201246 and MC-216227.

The bug

Dyed terracotta still appears to be based on the pre-1.12 color scheme.

While terracotta is meant to have a more reddish tinge than other dyed blocks, it's clear to see that, even ignoring the tinge in question, the colors of terracotta are still considerably different from other dyed blocks.

How to reproduce

  • Build the setup as shown in the attachment below in 1.11.2. 

[media]
  • Look at the setup you just built.

  • Take note of how the colors of the two blocks are similar and have the same color scheme.

  • Rebuild an identical setup in the current version of the game.

  • Look at the setup you just built.

  • → ❌  Notice how the colors of the two blocks are not similar, therefore indicating terracotta still uses the pre-1.12 color scheme.

Expected results

The expected behavior would be that terracotta would have a more consistent color scheme with other dyed blocks, while still maintaining a reddish tinge.

Actual results

Terracotta is still based on dye colors as they were prior to 1.12, making these textures outdated as a result (and as such sharing the incorrectly used old color scheme with MC-214641 and MC-214643).

How to fix

Terracotta blocks should be retextured as to use the newer color scheme, while still maintaining the faint redness of terracotta. MC-161716 could be fixed alongside this incredibly easily.

Linked issues

Attachments

Comments 6

I can also confirm that this is an issue. Here's some clear information regarding what the problem is and what the expected behavior should be.

The Bug:

Terracotta still uses the pre-1.12 color scheme.

Steps to Reproduce:

  • Build the setup as shown in the attachment below. 

[media]
  • Enable the "Programmer Art" resource pack.

  • Look at the setup you just built.

  • Take note of how the colors of the two blocks are similar and have the same color scheme.

  • Switch to the "Default" textures of the game.

  • Look at the setup you just built.

  • → ❌  Notice how the colors of the two blocks are not similar, therefore indicating terracotta still uses the pre-1.12 color scheme.

Expected Behavior:

The expected behavior would be that terracotta wouldn't use the pre-1.12 color scheme. Instead, its color should be altered to make the color scheme of other blocks.

I thought that wool colors were changed before the texture update, and therefore their old versions wouldn't be in Programmer Art?

Can confirm in 21w39a.

Confirmed that Programmer Art does not change wool colors back to the pre-1.12 shades (I have no idea why this ticket was modified to state so) - reproduction steps amended.

Yep, that was a mistake on my end, apologies. Can confirm this in both 1.17.1 and 21w44a. Here's a side-by-side comparison of the terracotta color scheme before and after the texture update.

[media]

muzikbike

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Textures and models

outdated-textures

1.17.1, 21w39a, 21w44a

Retrieved