mojira.dev
MC-238604

/locatebiome does not always pick up a biome and is inaccurate

See screenshot, I used /locatebiome a few blocks from the present coordinates and got a biome at 324 ~ neg220, but then I moved a few blocks and the /locatebiome didn't pick up the biome at all when it should have.

Default world gen, no special settings. Latest 1.18 snapshot 21w40a.

I've also had it where moving just a few blocks locates another of the same biome but hundreds of blocks more distant.

Attachments

Comments 5

This happens because the command only searches for biomes relative to your current height position, which is tracked in MC-206286 already.

Height remains the same. If though you mean relative no matter what my height (I think that's what you mean), I was still only maybe a few dozen blocks away from the original reading, not enough to warrant it changing.

A drip stone cave is, maximally, only going to be a difference of, say, 128 blocks (the height of potential, give or take). I would need to then, at minimum, move 128 blocks horizontally AND already be on the threshold of it being too far away, which I believe is several thousand blocks, at least 3,000+. As you can see here, I was not.

I tested it a bit more. I think I understand now.

So whatever Y coordinate I am at it scans ONLY on that Y coordinate. So I could have dripstone caves right beneath my feet, but it ignores that because it's not reaching to the Y I'm at.

Is that how it currently works? If so, that's in a way beneficial, but mostly not...

Can we close this ticket please, I'm not sure it's relevant anymore.

It not scanning on Y is still a relevant issue, as you yourself pointed out.

Rick Nielson

(Unassigned)

Unconfirmed

(Unassigned)

21w40a

Retrieved