Title says it all. It just plays over it.
Possibly related to MC-35856
Linked issues
is duplicated by 40
relates to 1
Comments 22
Dinnerbone has spoken, he said it's intended.
I guess "Works as Intended" isn't the best expression, it might be more of a "Won't fix"
Are you kidding me? So every time I want to hear a jukebox song first I have to turn down my music volume??? That is just hilarious.
Looks like I need to change all of my music settings of my RP, for my RPG map to work as I was looking forward to. With all those nice features from the new sound system THIS bug ruins the whole concept.. at least they've fixed the Multiply songs playing in the background but still it makes absolutely no sense at all to have the background music on. Every playsound command with custom sound or even music would play along with the background music which is absurd to my opinion..
Thank you for stealthily deleting my comment, mods. I didn't know the shift-key offended you so much. I'll keep this in mind from now on.
As I said:
1. Multiple tracks playing at once is not relaxing.
2. It did not happen before 1.7.
3. Requiring us to manually turn off music every time we play a jukebox and remembering to turn it back on afterwards is not acceptable.
@Hawk - No problem, you want to discuss an issue fine. You want to yell and scream at people, make demands, you will be muted this is not a forum, take it to the suggestion forums on reddit. Hence why I didn't mute the other comment you made about this subject on another ticket, because you phrased it like a reasonable person, and why I will not mute the comment above. Just keep in mind if you are not providing information or discussion in a reasonable manner, to help the discussion of the issue progress, then you will be muted.
Saying that the background music should stop when a jukebox starts playing is like saying that the background music should stop whenever a mob makes a sound. Jukebox music is a part of the game, just like any other sounds. If you don't like the background music, just turn it off.
@Isaac King: That comparison is inane. Background music and game sounds are two different things and they can coexist (source: almost every computer game ever made). Background music and in-game music are the same thing and cannot coexist, unless they are specifically designed to harmonize and sync (source: almost every computer game ever made).
Let's not forget that prior to the update that changed this, Minecraft did not play both music tracks at the same time. Find me one single example of a person who complained about this.
@@unknown: For what players do you want to stop the background music ? For all players, even those thousands of blocks away from the jukebox ? For those 32 blocks around the jukebox which may can hear a faint sound of the jukebox ?
Same for noteblocks ?
For those 32 blocks around the jukebox which may can hear a faint sound of the jukebox ?
Yes.
Edit: quoted too much. (My answer is "no" for noteblocks).
For feature suggestions or changes please see: Minecraft Suggestions on Reddit.
Michael McCluskey I totally agree with you, it's very annoying when you are listening to your favourite song and background music starts to play.